Deutsche Bahn bosses choose up bonuses as passengers undergo – DW – 12/11/2023 | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

In the wake of the GDL railroad union’s most up-to-date strike for higher wages and dealing circumstances, a report has emerged claiming that the highest administration of Germany’s rail operator, Deutsche Bahn, will apparently obtain bonuses totaling nearly €5 million ($5.4 million) for 2022.

This was divulged on Monday by public broadcasters NDR, WDR and every day Southgerman newspaper who stated that they had entry to Deutsche Bahn’s long-term calculation mannequin for bonuses.

Bonuses are supposed to be an award for good efficiency. But many long-suffering rail clients shall be scratching their heads in amazement and questioning how that is potential given Deutsche Bahn’s lengthy record of issues.

The trick, it seems, is to offset areas by which targets have been missed in opposition to different areas by which targets have been exceeded. It implies that the fundamental salaries of the 9 members of the chief will rise from a complete of round €4 million to round €9 million in 2022.

According to the report, Deutsche Bahn solely barely exceeded its personal targets within the space of “women in leadership and employee satisfaction” in 2022. However, the bonus was up by 175%, says the report. The govt board members stand to rake in round €1.6 million for this goal alone.

The paperwork additionally present that Deutsche Bahn exceeded its self-imposed goal for CO2 financial savings by 2%, the investigative community reported. CEO Richard Lutz, for instance, is claimed to have obtained nearly €440,000 in bonus funds.

Railway glitches do not have an effect on bosses’ earnings

According to the report, the bonus system seems to be set to be revamped subsequent yr. Deutsche Bahn board members would then obtain a better proportion of their wage as a set wage whereas the proportion of bonuses could be lowered.

Deutsche Bahn’s supervisory board, which incorporates federal authorities and commerce union representatives, units the parameters of the bonus system.

In future, assembly targets can have much less relevance for the rail bosses’ salaries. Whether a practice is working late, is canceled or overbooked will even have much less of an affect. Other issues like trains stopping “indefinitely” mid-route, air-con methods failing in midsummer or the app failing to point out alternate options and delays will play much less of a job in figuring out their salaries.

A high-speed Italian train at a train platform
Italy has expanded its long-distance community lately and invested billions in modernization tasksImage: Gian Mattia D’Alberto/ZUMAPRESS/image alliance

Germany’s nationwide practice system has numerous room for enchancment, not least regarding the punctuality of long-distance trains. Last yr, each third practice was greater than six minutes late. The scenario was higher on regional companies, the place just below a tenth of regional trains failed to achieve their vacation spot on time.

The difficulty of trains not working on time is a significant grievance for passengers. Factoring in delays means they have to adapt their journey plans accordingly to keep away from lacking connecting trains or appointments. That places off numerous potential passengers at a time when Deutsche Bahn wants to search out methods of squaring the circle to draw extra clients and enhance practice freight quantity if it desires to attain its local weather targets by 2030.

Deutsche Bahn: Too little funding

“Today’s unpunctuality is the result of 20 years of misguided transport and rail policy,” says Christian Böttger, professor of business engineering on the Berlin University of Applied Sciences. In the final 20 years, funding in rail infrastructure has been reduce, whereas on the identical time extra trains have been working.

“The network is simply overloaded,” says Böttger. In distinction to Luxembourg and Switzerland, who invested round €575 per capita and €450 per capita in rail infrastructure respectively, the determine in Germany is simply €114.

For the vast majority of Germans, mobility means touring by automotive, and that guides politicians’ insurance policies.

In addition, for the previous 15 years Deutsche Bahn has steadfastly maintained that its rail community infrastructure is in good working order. A current report, nevertheless, struck a special tone, observing that the community was “old” and “prone to faults.”

“That’s a huge scandal,” says rail skilled Böttger. “The federal government has spent millions to check these figures again and has always confirmed that the network is in a great condition.”

He factors out that there isn’t any inquiry committee and that nobody is asking whether or not the administration and supervisory boards needs to be held accountable.

In an effort to enhance its picture, Deutsche Bahn is planning a refurbishment program value billions of euros, with the purpose of restoring closely used sections of the rail community. Ultimately, Deutsche Bahn desires to have a high-performance community in place by 2030. This would contain bettering 40 routes to make sure extra reliability and a better frequency of trains.

Deutsche Bahn refurbishment by 2030

“We are now facing a historic turning point,” says Pro-Rail Alliance, a non-profit advocacy group for the development of rail transport. The authorities coalition in Berlin desires to considerably enhance funding in rail infrastructure within the price range for 2024.

“There is significantly more money than before; that is the good news,” says Böttger. However, a big a part of this cash is required to mitigate the affect of excessive inflation, he says.

In addition, the federal government had promised an additional €45 billion by 2027 “and now only around half is being provided by the federal government from the budget and climate protection fund,” he says.

A Hokkaido Shinkansen bullet train travels near Shin-Hakodate-Hokuto Station
While Germany’s railway community has to accommodate long-distance, regional and freight trains on one community, Japan has a separate community for its bullet trainsImage: Hiroki Ochimizu/Jiji Press/dpa/image alliance

The cash shall be used to renovate the high-speed railway traces however won’t be sufficient to construct new traces. Böttger doesn’t anticipate these measures to enhance punctuality, as they do not deal with the fundamental downside of overloaded networks.

The authorities has earmarked €90 billion as a precedence to construct new traces. In addition, an additional €50 billion are wanted for the so-called Deutschlandtakt, a venture that might join Germany’s main cities with trains working not less than each hour. Another €30 billion must be pumped into freight transport, which has lengthy been working a deficit.

“But there is no overview of the actual figures,” says Böttger. “And I don’t think the government wants there to be an overview either, because the result would be somewhat embarrassing, as it would show that the political goals are not financially viable.”

To make issues worse, there will not be sufficient planners and development firms to hold out the refurbishment work, says Böttger.

Is Deutsche Bahn too massive?

For years, specialists have beneficial splitting up Deutsche Bahn in order that the rail community and operations are managed by totally different firms.

However, Transport Minister Volker Wissing, of the neoliberal Free Democrats, is just not impressed. He’s planning a brand new infrastructure firm which might concentrate on the upkeep and growth of the rail community individually from rail operations. This firm is because of begin work on Jan. 1, 2024.

Other international locations, such because the Netherlands, Denmark, Sweden and the UK, have discovered a approach to make the separation of community and operations work. “But it’s not a magic solution,” cautions Böttger.

Rail clients mustn’t anticipate an enchancment in rail journey anytime quickly. On the opposite, issues will worsen earlier than they get higher, as busy routes must be shut down utterly at instances for upkeep and refurbishment.

“In view of the list of problems and the visible solutions, I doubt that the railroad’s accumulated problems can really be resolved in the next 10 years,” says Böttger.

This article was translated from German.

Truly revolutionary? Germany’s €49 public transport ticket

To view this video please allow JavaScript, and think about upgrading to an online browser that helps HTML5 video