Pedro Bravo: “Today if you are quiet it seems like you are annoying” | Culture | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

Journalist, screenwriter and creator of essays, fiction and podcasts, He just isn’t precisely Pedro Bravo (Madrid, 51 years outdated) of those that stay silent and, nonetheless, he has simply revealed Silence! Manifesto in opposition to noise, restlessness and haste (Debate), a relaxed reflection in opposition to the noise that invitations us to speak much less and hear extra. It just isn’t, as its again cowl warns, a self-help e-book, though due to its entertaining type and its informative vocation it will probably function a lifeline in these occasions when the chaos that surrounds us barely permits us to take heed to ourselves. . He acknowledges that he has been tempted to stay silent. “But it seemed appropriate to raise questions that help people realize that there is another way to go through life.”

Ask: Why not do like John Cage with 4′33′’ and depart the essay clean?

Answer: John Cage's train remains to be very legitimate. What he did with that work, leaving the rating clean and listening to nothing however the ambient sound throughout that point, not solely demonstrates that absolute silence is unimaginable, but additionally how tough it’s for us to face the problem of the pause, the empty. The e-book, though brief, is stuffed with textual content, after all, however what I attempt to do with it’s to point out that silence is useful. Being silent, stopping, observing, listening is wholesome; proper now, greater than ever.

P. It says that stillness is a means of shifting, of being ourselves. Does the motion steal our id?

R. We inform ourselves that, as a species, we’re made to maneuver, to find, to advance and but, what we discover most tough is stillness and silence. My thesis is that this silence and stillness are actions of resistance and, due to this fact, are a type of motion. And that, if we put them into follow, maybe we’ll uncover one other means of being ourselves that’s way more harmonious and balanced.

P. His reflections on silence inevitably lead him to return to noise many times. What is noise for you? Can we stay with out it?

R. Noise is these low-fidelity sounds that we endure each day in cities, and typically additionally within the countryside, and that make us sick and stop us from appreciating plenty of issues that reconcile us with our being. They are the ideas that fear us and make us distort actuality. The inhuman pace and nervousness imposed by the financial mannequin. The content material designed to hook us that firms within the care business launch to us. Can we stay with out noise? If we wish to stay extra peacefully, I’d say sure.

P. He factors out that social networks have turned us into brand-people who see others as competitors. Isn't that a little bit scary?

R. Well, it's not simply social media. The evolution of the financial mannequin has led us to be more and more individualistic and narcissistic. With the rise of networks and different weapons of the eye economic system, that course of has accelerated. Now we’re billions of selves unable to hear and making an attempt to rise above one another. Not solely is it scary, it's additionally extraordinarily boring.

With the rise of networks and different weapons of the eye economic system, we at the moment are billions of selves making an attempt to rise above one another

P. Have cities change into uninhabitable locations?

R. For many individuals, sure. Inequality and exclusion are rising, and noise, concern, and nervousness are growing. But not solely within the cities. What we name the countryside, the agricultural, can also be dominated by the mannequin that’s imposed from town, it really works for it in the identical situations of exploitation. It is turning into tough to stay properly, which for me is synonymous with dwelling peacefully.

P. Is silence an anti-capitalist ideology?

R. Silence is a device of resistance. For me it’s one thing way more disruptive, transversal, profound and complicated, whereas on the similar time being a quite simple idea. Is it anti-capitalist? Right now, I’d say, paraphrasing Eskorbuto, that he’s anti-everything. At least anti-everything that’s not pure and due to this fact human.

P. Have you ever felt that discrimination that introverts endure that you simply discuss within the e-book?

R. I don't know if it's discrimination, however it’s discomfort. Today one has the sensation of not being understood, of going in opposition to the present, of being bothered exactly by being silent. A superb a part of our societies have tended in the direction of show and chatter and excluding those that, by temperament, will not be like that. It occurs in faculties, at work, in leisure… Letting individuals be as they’re, listening to them, is a good way to be taught new issues.

Letting individuals be as they’re, listening to them, is a good way to be taught new issues

P. The e-book says issues just like the human obsession with discovering options is a part of the issue, however on the similar time you make an awesome effort to not fall into fatalism. Can we be optimistic?

R. What I keep is that optimism is a sort of imposition, a doctrine of financial faith that stops us from deviating from the marked route. We consider that we’re happening the flawed path however we’re satisfied that, as in fictional tales, somebody or one thing will come to save lots of us. Something or somebody from the identical system that has introduced us right here. Perhaps the one strategy to be optimistic is to begin being a pessimist, that’s, to not deny the apparent.

P. After studying the e-book you wish to run away, till you notice that you simply don't know the place to run both. Where ought to we go?

R. As a primary step, to silence, to pause, to calm, to remark, to listening. To the atenttion. And, from there, to what it reveals to us.

All the tradition that goes with you awaits you right here.

Subscribe

Babelia

The literary information analyzed by one of the best critics in our weekly publication

RECEIVE IT

Subscribe to proceed studying

Read with out limits

_

https://elpais.com/cultura/2024-02-29/pedro-bravo-hoy-si-estas-callado-parece-que-molestas.html