Immigration: The majority sees Germany on the restrict in the case of migration | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

GIs there nonetheless one thing like a welcoming tradition for immigrants and refugees in Germany? Or, given the financial disaster and the pressure on infrastructure and social methods, have rejection and skepticism lengthy since prevailed?

Since 2012, the Bertelsmann Foundation has been monitoring perceptions and attitudes in the direction of migration and integration at common intervals. With the research “Culture of Welcome in Times of Crisis”, the inspiration is now presenting its present survey. It reveals that the view of immigration to Germany and its results is more and more characterised by ambivalence.

Source: Infographic WELT

On the one hand, a majority of these surveyed proceed to watch a basically intact tradition of welcome on the a part of the state authorities within the municipalities and the native inhabitants – particularly in the direction of labor and academic migrants. At the identical time, nevertheless, there’s rising concern about extra prices for the welfare state, housing shortages in metropolitan areas and issues in colleges. Overall, unfavourable perceptions at the moment predominate when assessing the results of immigration. An impact that researchers have already noticed in recent times after giant waves of immigration.

Specifically, round 2,000 folks aged 14 and over had been requested within the consultant survey how immigrants, asylum seekers and refugees had been welcomed. Compared to labor and academic migrants, 78 % of these surveyed see such a welcoming tradition among the many state authorities within the municipalities and 73 % among the many native inhabitants.

Source: Infographic WELT

The angle in the direction of refugees and asylum seekers is completely different – by this the Bertelsmann Foundation means all individuals who come to Germany for humanitarian causes. Compared to them, 67 % of these surveyed understand a welcoming tradition within the municipalities, however solely 53 % within the native inhabitants. This reveals that expert immigration is mostly seen extra positively than asylum immigration. In a long-term comparability, each values ​​are comparatively steady regardless of a slight downward development – for the Bertelsmann Foundation that is proof of a “robust culture of welcome in German society”.

Worries are rising considerably

However, there are clear regional variations. In East Germany specifically, the inhabitants's angle in the direction of refugees and asylum seekers is somewhat unfavourable. Only 37 % are conscious that the inhabitants welcomes this group. In West Germany the worth is 56 %.

Source: Infographic WELT

A have a look at the previous twelve years reveals that the event of the welcoming tradition has developed in waves. Large immigration actions reminiscent of these in 2015/16 in the course of the Syrian conflict and in 2022/2023 after the beginning of the conflict in Ukraine resulted in a decreased willingness to just accept folks, after an preliminary nice willingness to assist. “The society, which is fundamentally open to immigration, is reacting to a sharp increase in refugee migration in some places with tendencies to close down. In times of crisis, the basic ambivalent attitude tends towards increased skepticism,” says the research.

A majority of 60 % are actually of the opinion that Germany can not settle for extra migrants as a result of it’s at its limits. In the 2021 survey it was solely 36 %. The predominant motive for the pessimistic angle is the priority that the social methods, the housing market and the infrastructure will probably be overwhelmed.

Source: Infographic WELT

Accordingly, 78 % of these surveyed anticipate extra prices for the welfare state, 74 % worry a housing scarcity in metropolitan areas, 73 % anticipate conflicts between locals and immigrants; 71 % are apprehensive about issues in colleges. These values ​​are greater than within the 2021 and 2019 surveys. They now attain an analogous degree to 2017, though issues in regards to the housing scarcity have elevated considerably since then.

According to the research, there’s a robust consensus on the subject of job alternatives: 87 % agree with the assertion that the state ought to be certain that migrants are allowed to work rapidly in Germany. 75 % help the concept of ​​fastened distribution quotas throughout the EU, relying on the scale and financial energy of a rustic.

additionally learn

Federal Minister of the Interior Nancy Faeser on the flight from Peru to Ecuador

“The results suggest that the increased skepticism towards migration is primarily not due to a negative attitude towards immigrants, but primarily to concern about the economic and social capacities for successful reception and integration,” says Ulrike Wieland , integration knowledgeable on the Bertelsmann Foundation. “In order to counter migration skepticism, immigration to Germany should be better managed.”

What obstacles to integration do the respondents see?

The researchers additionally discovered some constructive findings on immigration: round 63 % of these surveyed consider that that is necessary for the settlement of worldwide corporations. 62 % consider that Germany has fewer aged folks due to migration. In addition, a majority (61 %) are of the opinion that immigration makes life in Germany extra attention-grabbing.

However, solely 38 % of these surveyed consider that immigration brings extra revenue to the pension insurance coverage system; Only 47 % anticipate compensation for the scarcity of expert staff. The values ​​that measure the constructive points of immigration have not too long ago declined. Probably additionally as a result of within the query part on benefits and drawbacks no distinction was made between labor and asylum migration.

“The decreased confidence regarding the possible economic advantages of immigration may partly have to do with a selective perception that focuses primarily on refugee immigration and the costs initially incurred in this context,” says the research.

additionally learn


Labor migration from third nations reached a brand new excessive in 2022 with 71,046 folks. It is claimed that the majority of those migrants got here from India and the Western Balkans. In phrases of numbers, they’re clearly within the minority in comparison with those that have immigrated to the asylum system. According to the Federal Statistical Office, the full variety of asylum purposes in 2023 was 351,915. In addition, round 1.1 million conflict refugees from Ukraine had been counted in Germany by the top of December 2023.

When it involves the notion of obstacles to integration, mastery of the German language performs a distinguished position: 81 % of these surveyed see a scarcity of language abilities amongst immigrants as one of many largest obstacles to integration. However, this level has turn into much less necessary in comparison with earlier years – probably as a result of staff in lots of corporations may get by with English.

Here you can find content material from third events

In order to show embedded content material, your revocable consent to the transmission and processing of private knowledge is important, because the suppliers of the embedded content material require this consent as third occasion suppliers [In diesem Zusammenhang können auch Nutzungsprofile (u.a. auf Basis von Cookie-IDs) gebildet und angereichert werden, auch außerhalb des EWR]. By setting the swap to “on”, you comply with this (revocable at any time). This additionally contains your consent to the switch of sure private knowledge to 3rd nations, together with the USA, in accordance with Art. 49 (1) (a) GDPR. You can discover extra details about this. You can revoke your consent at any time utilizing the swap and privateness on the backside of the web page.

The lack of equal alternatives within the labor marketplace for immigrants (58 %), discrimination primarily based on origin (55 %) and the attachment of immigrants to their tradition of origin (53 %) are additionally talked about as obstacles to integration. One in two folks additionally think about the shortage of schooling amongst immigrants to be one of many largest obstacles.

However, the younger respondents as much as the age of 29 are extra optimistic in all of those areas than the typical inhabitants. The differing evaluation with regard to the scenario in colleges is especially placing: solely 48 % of youthful folks and even solely 34 % of scholars consider that immigration results in issues – in distinction to a transparent majority (71 %) on common of all these surveyed. Young individuals are additionally considerably extra assured that immigration can compensate for the scarcity of expert staff, make Germany much less growing older and make life extra attention-grabbing general.

For the Bertelsmann Foundation's “Culture of Welcome in Times of Crisis” research, the Verian opinion analysis institute carried out a consultant survey of two,005 folks in Germany aged 14 and over between October 18 and 25, 2023.