left-wing events in France play division… and second roles | EUROtoday

The story repeats itself. They might have chosen to unite and play the main roles in opposition to Renaissance and the National Rally in the course of the European elections on June 9. They finally most popular disunity. As in 2019, ecologists, rebels, socialists and communists are leaving in scattered order on the left for the European marketing campaign.

The New Popular, Ecological and Social Union (Nupes) constructed for the 2022 legislative elections didn’t lengthy resist the logic of the equipment, the strategic divergences and the substantive variations between the 4 most important left-wing forces.

As quickly as she was elected head of Europe Écologie-Les Verts (EELV) in December 2022, Marine Tondelier advocated an autonomous listing to construct a “great movement of political ecology”. Eager to free themselves from the Nupes, Fabien Roussel and the French Communist Party (PCF) rapidly adopted swimsuit, quickly adopted by the Socialist Party (PS), firstly of the 2023 faculty yr. Only La France insoumise (LFI) tried to the top to hold a method of union, going as far as to counsel that environmentalists take the lead in a standard listing. But this seemingly unifying speech was on the similar time weakened by the quite a few polemical positions and different invectives of Jean-Luc Mélenchon (see right here, right here and right here) all through 2023.

Read additionallyEuropean elections: the challenges of a high-risk vote

“There was a proposal for a joint list formulated by LFI which consisted of leaving the head of the list to environmentalists, but the latter refused. It’s a shame because things would undoubtedly have been different,” regrets MP Benjamin Lucas, a fervent supporter of the union and member of the Génération·s social gathering – member of Nupes, this small social gathering was torn over the query of an alliance within the European elections with LFI and finally selected not to participate. “However, I continue to think that until the deadline for submitting the lists, there is still hope. The campaigns have started, my comrades will be able to see that the voters want union,” he believes.

To differentiate your self, assaults come forth

A really optimistic view of the scenario, particularly for the reason that campaigns of each side formally started, the assaults have been coming.

Raphaël Glucksmann, head of the PS-Place publique listing, thus performs the Ukrainian card all through his interviews. “It is obvious that there is a gulf that separates us from La France insoumise on the question of war in Europe,” he declared once more, Sunday March 17, on BFMTV. “I think that this campaign will make it possible to decide the lines on the left on the question of the geopolitics of Europe, the relationship with dictatorships, the relationship with human rights, the relationship with violence,” he continued.

Read additionallyEuropeans: Ukraine on the coronary heart of the marketing campaign, a dangerous technique for Emmanuel Macron

For her half, the rebellious Manon Aubry responds by differentiating herself on the continuing battle between Israel and Hamas. “There are a lot of candidates who have talked about international law, but no one has talked about the ongoing humanitarian carnage in the Gaza Strip and the deaths in Gaza, with more children dying in the space of four months than “within the area of 4 years in all worldwide conflicts”, said during the first European debate, Thursday March 13 on Public Senate, the head of the LFI list, who does not hesitate to speak of “genocide” when Raphaël Glucksmann refuses.

The communist candidate, Léon Deffontaines, targets rebels and environmentalists at the same time, two parties opposed to nuclear energy. He did not hesitate to affirm, during the same debate on Public Senate, that “anti-nuclear activists are the environmentalists of the past”. Furthermore, determined to convince voters who voted “no” to the 2005 European constitutional treaty to vote PCF, the communists are attempting to show that Jean-Luc Mélenchon was not at all times against the development of a liberal Europe. Their marketing campaign clip thus unearthed an archive from 1992 through which the previous socialist senator helps the Maastricht Treaty, which notably put in place the ban on any annual public deficit larger than 3% of GDP.

Finally, even when Marie Toussaint advocates “gentleness in politics” and resists attacking her left-wing opponents, ecologists repeatedly remind us of what units them aside from the socialists, who only a few months in the past hoped to type a standard listing with them . “We are not going to campaign with Carole Delga and her A69 in Occitanie, Alain Rousset, who supports megabasins in New Aquitaine, or Loïg Chesnais-Girard, who supports agribusiness in Brittany”, insisted in January the boss of EELV, Marine Tondelier, in Le Monde.

“From the moment we are separated, each will want to exacerbate what differentiates them from the other, that's obvious”, laments Benjamin Lucas, whereas the left is now launched right into a “small horse race”, dixit Manon Aubry in Libération, or a “fight of dwarves”, in keeping with the expression utilized by the socialist deputy Philippe Brun in this system “Backseat”.

“Risk is a scenario where everyone writes the story that suits them”

Divided, Marie Toussaint, Manon Aubry, Raphaël Glucksmann and Léon Deffontaines can solely purpose at finest, in keeping with the polls, for third place behind the lists of Jordan Bardella (National Rally) and Valérie Hayer (Renaissance) – the RN listing collects 31% of voting intentions, the Renaissance listing 18%, the PS-Place publique listing 11.5%, the EELV listing 8.5%, the LFI listing 7% and the PCF listing 3.5%, in keeping with the most recent Ipsos survey printed on March 11 in Le Monde.

The environmentalist candidate, the rebellious candidate and the socialist candidate will due to this fact attempt to do what Yannick Jadot (EELV) achieved in 2019, who completed behind the main duo RN and Renaissance, whereas the target of the communist candidate shall be to this time exceed the 5% threshold, synonymous with the election of no less than one MEP – the PCF had solely obtained 2.49% of the votes in 2019, when the PS listing had obtained 6.19%, the LFI listing 6.31% and the EELV listing 13.48%.

Read additionallyEuropean elections: how does it work?

However, no political classes may be drawn from the outcomes of June 9. After Yannick Jadot's rating within the 2019 European elections, environmentalists claimed management on the left. Two years later, after the 2021 regional elections, it was the Socialist Party which boasted due to its victories in 5 areas. But in 2022, the rebellious Jean-Luc Mélenchon gained 21.95% of the votes within the first spherical of the presidential election, when the ecologist Yannick Jadot completed at 4.63% and the socialist Anne Hidalgo topped out at 1.75 %.

“Everyone will interpret what they need to interpret and see what they need to see. The threat is a state of affairs the place everybody writes the story that fits them, warns Benjamin Lucas. makes us offended as a result of we don’t grasp the historic second that’s taking part in out, with a threat of seeing the intense proper come to energy in 2027. If we have been collectively, we might be in entrance of Renaissance and we’d play the ultimate in opposition to the intense proper . It can be a totally completely different story, together with for 2027.”

Post-2024 is also on everyone's minds. Even though they are today divided and seeking to differentiate themselves from each other, all the left-wing parties, apart from the PCF, claim to want a common candidate for the next presidential election. Jean-Luc Mélenchon symbolizes this paradox, affirming last weekend that he wanted to unite while launching violent diatribes towards his hypothetical partners.

He first made the rebels the one representatives of the Nupes within the European elections, calling for the June 9 vote to be reworked right into a “first round” of the 2027 presidential election which might be decisive for the union of the left. “If people on the left vote for us, there will be a union, if they do not vote for us, there will be no union,” insisted in the course of the LFI assembly, Saturday March 16 in Villepinte, the triple presidential candidate (2012, 2017, 2022), who nonetheless leaves doubt as to his intentions for the following race for the Élysée.

Then he castigated, the following day on France 3, “those who decided to divide us” and hoped that “the French left would punish them” for having every made a separate listing for the European deadline. A humorous option to attain out.