Puan: an Aristotelian comedy for Platonics at coronary heart (***) | EUROtoday

As is understood, within the image The faculty of Athens of Raphael, Plato factors to the sky and Aristotle, with the ethics in his hand, he asks for calm and, extra modestly, settles for the bottom. That, which traditionally has handed for a nice allegory about idealism versus realism, was in reality at all times a joke; a philosophical joke. It was by no means humorous, but it surely was a advantage. And this different factor is a theological joke; a kind of joke that shouldn’t be confused with communist jokes, which, as is understood, are solely humorous if everybody likes them. And so.

There is a second in Ma'am during which the philosophy professor who acts because the protagonist explains to a not so venerable previous girl (however indecently wealthy, that’s) the idea of Dasein Heideggerian. Shortly earlier than or shortly after, the girl falls in love with the precision of the neologism. And he falls asleep, in fact. Let's say that’s the stage. Philosophical jokes are like that and it’s not advisable to ask them for greater than they’re able to giving. Let's say that all the philosophical comedy of the Argentines is honed in that observe. Mara Alch y Benjamn Naishtat which takes its title from the headquarters of the Faculty of Philosophy and Letters in Buenos Aires the place it takes place. The most glorious, enigmatic and influential of the thinkers of the twentieth century became a easy excuse to entertain the bourgeoisie that’s too bored, too lazy and too rich.

There are a number of methods to cope with Ma'am. And all (or nearly all) work precisely. A) As a problem, it’s about making one joke after one other the place The place of the legendary Jaimito (or whoever) is now occupied by Hobbes, Rousseau, Sartre or the aforementioned Heidegger. Also Plato. And Aristotle. B) As a metaphor of existence (like this, typically), the thought is to make mud with the absurdity of seeing probably the most noble of the branches of thought transformed right into a battlefield the place probably the most fundamental passions are settled: vainness. , envy or resentment. And C) as an x-ray of the Argentine scenario at this time, the understanding is legitimate that the precision and brilliance of the argument doesn’t matter, the one who shouts the loudest wins. Things of despair.

The story of Marcelo is instructed, performed by Marcelo Subiotto, a professor of Philosophy designated (or condemned, relying on the way you take a look at it) to be the successor of the lifelong professor. When the latter died abruptly, he was stunned to attend his defenestration due to a younger and seductive colleague who had arrived from Europe (right here, Leonardo Sbaraglia). To proceed with the metaphor above, the primary factors to the sky, bald as he’s, and the second conforms to the bottom. One idealist, the opposite calculating and lifelike.

By María Alch, along with showing in La nia santa of Lucrecia Martel, we knew above all of the movie submerged household just like the quintessence of hypnosis dropped at the display screen. From Benjamn Naishtat, what was simply earlier than was a thriller atmospheric and poisoned by cross-references (postmodern in its personal means) sunk within the Argentina of the 70s that bears the title of Rojo. If we apply Aristotelian logic (sorry), There is not any potential type or syllogism that leads, neither via it nor via it, to the comedy with an Italian taste. (due to its verbosity) that now makes an look.

And, regardless of all the things, nobody can accuse them of not understanding and masterfully making use of the tempos that the style calls for. Ma'am It turns into entangled in human miseries whereas lulling the viewer to sleep with the clearest and noblest reasoning. And within the distinction she manages to create a pleasant mess during which nobody goes unpunished: neither the wealthy with out conscience nor the poor with conscience nor these within the center who’ve already ceased to exist. You might say that it’s an Aristotelian comedy, as a result of it’s exact and measured, however with a Platonic coronary heart, as a result of it’s idealistic and even candid. But there are issues and one no much less is the sustained effort to be tremendously clever with each step he takes. It exhausts this fixed effort to seem, maybe embarrassed, to be one thing else, a lot greater, than the comedy that it finally is. Philosophical jokes are like that.

—

Direccin: Mara Alch, Benjamin Naishtat. Interpreters: Leonardo Sbaraglia, Marcelo Subiotto, Julieta Zylberberg, Alejandra Flechner, Cristina Banegas. Duracin: 111 minutes. Argentina Nationality.