Giovanna Roncado: One of the scientists who generates essentially the most cash in Spain doesn’t obtain a single euro for her discoveries | Science | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

The biologist Giovanna Roncador is experiencing a “surreal” state of affairs. She is among the scientists who generates essentially the most cash in Spain due to her innovations, however she doesn’t obtain a single euro. Roncador, born within the Italian metropolis of Trento 57 years in the past, works in the most effective establishments specialised in most cancers on the planet, the National Cancer Research Center (CNIO), in Madrid. She directs the Monoclonal Antibodies Unit, molecules which can be designed within the laboratory to bind particularly to sure cells and have the option, for instance, to diagnose lymphomas. The sale of those antibodies to worldwide corporations generates roughly a million euros per 12 months in exploitation rights for the CNIO, however the establishment has not shared the advantages with the inventors since 2020 as a result of a Kafkaesque bureaucratic mess.

“I don't know what to do anymore, it's a very frustrating situation. I am truly tired and unmotivated, which is why I have stopped contacting companies to license the antibodies. Why aren't those who work well rewarded? It doesn't matter if you do it right or wrong,” laments the biologist. Roncador was working designing antibodies on the University of Oxford (United Kingdom) when she was recruited in 2000 to assist discovered the brand new most cancers reference middle in Spain. She says that nobody demanded it of her, however after every new antibody developed for CNIO analysis, she made some extent of contacting the main corporations to current the advances to them. If they had been , Roncador herself negotiated the agreements, attaining millionaire revenue for her middle, a public basis hooked up to the Ministry of Science.

The Italian researcher says that her father was a truck driver, however he left behind the wheel to arrange his personal automobile shopping for and promoting firm in his city, Mezzolombardo. “My father is very entrepreneurial and very good at negotiating, that's where he comes from,” she explains. Roncador's biggest success was growing an antibody that particularly targets a subtype of white blood cells, which has revealed new mechanisms of the immune response. Her staff designed it together with her colleague Alison Banham, from the University of Oxford. The British firm has been gathering its working income since 2004, however Roncador solely acquired them between 2014, when the CNIO board lastly permitted a distribution regulation, and 2019, simply earlier than the Ministry of Finance stopped funds.

The biologist provides an instance. If an organization earns 100,000 euros a 12 months promoting one in every of its antibodies, the CNIO receives about 15,000. After deducting bills and the share for the Spanish establishment, lower than 6,000 euros would attain the inventors. In the case of her most profitable antibody, virtually half would go to Oxford and, of the remaining roughly 3,000 euros, Giovanna Roncador would obtain 65% (about 1,900 euros yearly); her proper hand, the biologist Lorena Maestre, 28% (about 800 euros); and the top of the Protein Production Unit, Jorge Martínez Torrecuadrada, 7% (about 200 euros). Roncador and Maestre, essentially the most affected as a result of they generate essentially the most cash, sued the CNIO earlier than a social court docket in Madrid, on September 19, 2022, to keep away from the expiration of their rights, in keeping with the documentation they’ve had. entry EL PAÍS.

The researcher estimates that the sale of 65 of her antibodies has produced greater than 8.5 million euros of web revenue within the public coffers of the CNIO since 2004. The establishment started to share income with its inventors in 2014, however stopped doing so with the cash of 2020 and subsequent years. A report from the General Intervention of the State Administration – the inner management physique of the state public sector – then beneficial “the immediate suspension” of the distribution system. “Royalties are a regulatory concept that does not exist in our legislation and lacks regulatory development,” defended the auditors, assigned to the Ministry of Finance. The report additionally urged recalculating the advantages downwards, deducting extra of the middle's bills.

Snorer sighs, sitting in her small workplace, embellished with pictures of the singer David Bowie. “Such a hyper-bureaucratized system discourages the entrepreneurial spirit,” she maintains. “I am exhausted from investing my time and energy in battles that other countries around us have completely overcome,” she emphasizes. The biologist is the founder and present president of the European Monoclonal Antibody Network, with laboratories in 13 nations.

The biologist Giovanna Roncador, at the National Cancer Research Center, in Madrid.
The biologist Giovanna Roncador, on the National Cancer Research Center, in Madrid.Alvaro Garcia

Fifty CNIO researchers wrote to the Ministry of Science on December 12, 2022 to speak that they thought of it “unacceptable” to should go to court docket to have the ability to acquire a share for his or her innovations. “It is not only about economic rights, but also the way to value and reward exceptionally done work and promote the transfer of knowledge, thus generating beneficial returns for research and institutions,” argued the signatories, amongst whom had been the director of the CNIO herself, María Blasco, and her predecessor, Mariano Barbacid.

The Ministry of Science responded two weeks later, emphasizing that the brand new Science Law, reformed in June 2022, already establishes that researchers within the state public sector will take “at least a third” of the advantages generated by the exploitation of their innovations. “I am giving the necessary impetus to expedite these last procedures as much as possible,” mentioned the then Secretary General of Research, Raquel Yotti, in her response, despatched on December 27, 2022.

The Kafkaesque course of continued the next 12 months. The CNIO administration explains that its specialists studied “multiple” options and despatched their official proposal for a brand new distribution system on November 20, to the General Intervention of the State Administration. A spokesperson for the Ministry of Finance confirms that they acquired it, however “due to some problem” it didn’t attain the suitable division till about 20 days in the past.

I’m exhausted from investing my time and power in battles that different nations round us have fully overcome.

Roncador and his colleagues are “outraged.” Taking under consideration solely the sale of antibodies, there are 23 CNIO scientists affected by non-payment, plus one other 27 who now work at different establishments. “It is intolerable that the lack of interest and bureaucracy prevent solving a problem that the center and the researchers themselves agree to solve, in accordance with the Law, approaching three years without a solution,” explains the Italian biologist. Licenses for innovations by CNIO scientists generated 1.6 million euros in 2023, 23% greater than the earlier 12 months.

The state of affairs is so uncommon that the CNIO administration itself helps the claims of the researchers who’ve sued the establishment for non-payment of exploitation rights. “In the other Spanish research centers this distribution does take place, provided for in current legislation. This is an anomaly that discriminates against CNIO researchers and significantly harms the center's innovative activity,” the administration explains to EL PAÍS. “The CNIO, an institution of scientific and innovation excellence in Spain, cannot be in a state of exception in relation to the distribution of operating profits,” he says.

Biochemist Eva Ortega Paíno, new Secretary General of Research on the Ministry of Science, is aware of the issue very properly. She was the scientific director of the CNIO Biobank till the minister, Diana Morant, employed her three months in the past. “At the Ministry we are aware of this situation and we are monitoring it to ensure its resolution. We trust that it will be evaluated as soon as possible,” says Ortega. Everyone is ready for the response from the Treasury.

In the foyer of the CNIO there’s a big banner in English and Spanish: “Decent salaries NOW at CNIO! Fair salaries NOW at the CNIO!” The works council put in it as a result of the oldest staff earn little greater than when the middle was based 1 / 4 of a century in the past. Giovanna Roncador's wage is 2,681 euros, with 14 funds a 12 months. That of her quantity two, Lorena Maestre, is 1,794 euros. They are two of the scientists who generate essentially the most cash in Spain, in the most effective most cancers analysis facilities on the planet.

The CNIO administration assures that “until now it has not been possible to make promotions due to restrictions set by the General State Budgets.” Scientist Carmen Guerra, president of the works council, explains that this has created a paradoxical state of affairs: the brand new signings are available in incomes the utmost of the outdated wage tables, in order that they earn greater than the veterans, with their salaries de facto frozen for some time. quarter of a century. There is an audit underway to “remediate pay inequalities,” in keeping with administration. There are additionally fifteen complaints from CNIO staff in progress, in keeping with the president of the committee.

Guerra left the Jackson Laboratory, within the United States, to hitch the CNIO in 1998, with an thrilling supply. 1 / 4 of a century later, he says that he earns virtually the identical as he did then, 2,533 euros monthly (if divided into the 14 typical funds), regardless of having extra tasks. Guerra, a 57-year-old from Madrid, is the co-inventor of a mouse cell line with very fascinating genetic modifications to check the mechanisms of a gene concerned in thousands and thousands of tumors. The CNIO owes him tens of hundreds of euros in unpaid exploitation rights.

The biologist Lorena Maestre, born in Madrid 48 years in the past, is forceful. “What we are demanding are minuscule amounts if you compare them with what they earn in some companies, bankers, economists… It is ridiculous. It seems that we should be ashamed of receiving a few thousand euros,” she deplores. Roncador, subsequent to her, agrees: “This system is a competitive disadvantage with the rest of Europe, it makes our country very unattractive for leading scientists. We generate income for the CNIO of one million euros a year and it seems that we are asking for alms.”

Do you might have extra details about this case or different related ones? You can write to us at mansede@elpais.es. Follow MATERIA in Facebook, X, Instagram or subscribe right here to our bulletin.

Subscribe to proceed studying

Read with out limits

_


https://elpais.com/ciencia/2024-04-12/una-de-las-cientificas-que-mas-dinero-genera-en-espana-no-recibe-ni-un-euro-por-sus-descubrimientos.html