Controversy in France over the change of Notre Dame stained glass home windows with fashionable ones | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.


Just 5 years in the past, Parisians watched helplessly because the cathedral of Notre Dame It was consumed in a devastating fireplace that even introduced down its legendary spire, image of the sky of the French capital. Among the issues that have been saved and never affected are the stained glass designed by him architect Viollet-Le-Ducand which are actually the topic of controversy, after 5 years of reconstruction work.

The debate has been opened as a result of a part of these works shall be changed by extra modern ones. Notre Dame Cathedral has only some months left to reopen its doorways to the general public. It shall be December eighth. The arrow of the monument, 93 meters excessive and the work of Le Duc, has already been raised and the rehabilitation works, which have been carried out in keeping with the methods of the Middle Ages, are effectively superior and in keeping with the deliberate schedule.

The Minister of Culture, Rachida Dati, introduced a number of weeks in the past the opening of a contest to decide on the grasp craftsmen answerable for designing and carving these new stained glass home windows that shall be positioned in six of the seven chapels of the south nave of Notre Dame. It was the French president, Emmanuel Macron,who launched the concept of ​​altering them for extra fashionable ones, on the request of the archdiocese. She did so throughout a website go to in December 2023.

The profitable artists of the competition shall be introduced in Novemberprototypes of the works shall be displayed within the cathedral when it opens to the general public and can lastly get replaced in 2026. The historical stained glass home windows shall be displayed within the new museum that may open within the coming months.

The Church additionally helps changing these works, which have been left intact after the 2019 fireplace.

In France, with its resistance to alter and its standard dedication to inventive debate, there are two currents: that of these in favor of adjusting them in order that the medieval cathedral has no less than a twenty first century mark. In this group, along with Emmanuel Macron, there may be the French Church itself, which has requested that they get replaced.

At the alternative pole There are those that consider that it’s a patrimonial sacrilege as a result of this breaks the architectural unity of the monument. They referred to as it vandalism.. They argue that the works survived and remained intact regardless of the hearth and, subsequently, there isn’t any motive to alter such a invaluable factor. They add that these works won’t look the identical in a museum.

An on-line petition was launched a yr in the past, promoted by the journalist and artwork historian Didier Rykner, to ask for help in opposition to the alternative of stained glass. It already has 140,000 signatures and the target is to current the demand to the president once they handle to succeed in 150,000 signatures. They criticize that Macron has selected a nationwide monument.

The rehabilitation of the Notre Dame de Paris cathedral has sparked controversy from the start. The reconstruction of the well-known arrow, which for greater than a month has been rising once more over the sky of Paris, additionally confronted conservatives and people in favor of change, though lastly the reconstruction was carried out in an equivalent method to the unique.

These stained glass home windows shouldn’t be thought-about works in themselves. They are ornamental stained glass. Macron's presidency has marked the cathedral after the hearth. There is a scarcity of discomfort in attempting to switch Viollet-le-Duc when the hearth has already destroyed a part of his work, protested Rykner, promoter of the companies.

It just isn’t the primary controversy over the Notre Dame show instances. Already in 1939 they tried to switch them, after two years of hectic debate, however because the world was in the course of World War II, the brand new ones have been by no means put in. These cursed works, which have been designed however not positioned, stay at present on show within the cit du vitrail of Troyes, about 100 kilometers from Paris. It is an area devoted to selling the glass heritage of the area..

These days the newspaper Le Monde rescued a curious anecdote from the controversy, which displays very effectively how time passes, however there are issues that don’t change in France. It is an article from one other medium, Le Figaro, revealed in 1939. The textual content mentioned: At a time when financial considerations and obsession with struggle disturb intelligence and depress sensibilities, The Parisian public remains to be able to turning into obsessed with an issue of a creative nature..