The Senate adopts a controversial invoice geared toward regulating gender transitions amongst minors | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

Demonstration against transphobia and for the visibility of trans people in Paris, May 26, 2024.

The Senate adopted on Tuesday May 28 a invoice geared toward regulating gender transitions earlier than the age of 18, an initiative by the Republicans (LR) fiercely condemned by the left and associations. After some hesitation, the federal government introduced its opposition to the textual content.

The invoice from Senator LR Jacqueline Eustache-Brinio, adopted by 180 votes to 136, notably offers for a ban on hormonal therapies for minors and strict management of prescriptions for “puberty blockers”. These molecules make it doable to droop the event of secondary sexual traits (chest, voice, hair) regarding the gender with which the kid doesn’t establish.

This is'“to prevent minors questioning their gender from regretting medical treatments or sexual reassignment surgery following a wrong diagnosis”stated the writer of the textual content, sparking protests from the left.

“The real problems you have is that trans people exist and there is nothing you can do to stop it”retorted the ecologist Mélanie Vogel.

The textual content was adopted because of the virtually unanimous votes of the LR-centrist alliance, a majority within the Senate. The left and the Macronist group opposed it, whereas the Independent group with a majority Horizons didn’t take part within the vote. It has now been despatched to the National Assembly, however there’s at present no assure that it is going to be examined there.

“A transphobic offensive”

The debates had been a chance for the federal government to make clear its place, whereas vagueness reigned till the tip of the night over its exact intentions. But the Minister for Health, Frédéric Valletoux, after listening to all of the political teams, lastly rejected the initiative outright, denouncing “a totally dogmatic, subjective approach, where medical and scientific arguments have little importance”.

Also learn the decryption | Article reserved for our subscribers Transgender minors and hormone remedy: what the science says

Earlier within the day, a number of parliamentary sources had been warned by the manager of a authorities opinion known as “of wisdom”, neither favorable nor unfavorable, which had irritated even inside the presidential camp. Several Renaissance parliamentarians had in reality co-signed throughout the day a column revealed in The New Obs denouncing a “transphobic offensive”.

“We will not give our voice to an approach which is only a pretext to give credence to the most radical and most unjust and reactionary positions of our assembly”Renaissance senator Xavier Iacovelli was indignant in a public session.

Faced with criticism, the president of the LR senators, Bruno Retailleau, stepped as much as the plate within the hemicycle: “There is not on one side the camp of good and on the other side the camp of evil. There are not transphobes on one side and people with complete humanity on the other. This kind of statement is an insult”he stated, brandishing the “duty of precaution and prudence” in direction of minors.

Rapporteur on the invoice, Senator LR Alain Milon assured that it assured ” the balance “ between the necessity for “relieve the suffering of patients” And the one in all “limit recourse to irreversible interventions”.

Up to 2 years in jail for medical doctors

The model of the textual content submitted to the Senate for a vote plans to permit the prescription of puberty blockers to minors however inside a particular framework, inside “multidisciplinary reference centers” and solely after medical monitoring lasting a minimum of two years.

Read additionally | Article reserved for our subscribers Transgender minors: how the talk over puberty blockers has advanced within the UK

The prescription of crossed hormones to minors would, nevertheless, be prohibited, as would the manufacturing of “reassignment surgeries”. With a penalty of as much as two years' imprisonment and a superb of 30,000 euros for medical doctors who contravene these guidelines. “A worrying precedent”in response to Mr. Valletoux.


” Policy “

Every week, “Le Monde” analyzes present political points for you


Associations defending LGBT+ rights and quite a few senators have additionally criticized the inclusion on this textual content of an article devoted to the institution of a nationwide technique for baby psychiatry.

“Gender incongruence”, that’s to say the sensation of an inadequacy between the gender felt and that of start, has nevertheless been excluded from the class of psychological problems by the World Health Organization (WHO ) in 2018.

The World with AFP

Reuse this content material