Puccini’s Madama Butterfly on the Teatro Real: tragedy or success? | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

Updated

Of the three protagonists of the trio of masterpieces by Giacomo Puccini It is that this lady who most deserves the title of tragic character. The seamstress Mimí and the diva Floria Tosca are additionally victims of unresolved passions, however the case of Cio Cio San is distinguished as a result of she arrives condemned to the position of tragic heroine from the second her lover broadcasts that he’ll spend a while together with her after which marry her. with a “real American wife.” But Butterfly, who already considers herself Mrs. Benjamin Franklin Pinkerton, has given herself so obsessively and radically to her love ardour that the article of it, the fool lieutenant of the gunboat Lincoln, is nearly unimportant. She doesn’t sacrifice herself for him, however out of constancy to the exalted situation of tragic heroine.

The soprano mentioned Mirella Freni that she, who recorded the position, was not able to deciphering it on stage exactly due to the depth with which Puccini's music portrays the story of a fragile and clever creature, able to opposing abandonment and loneliness with a brave and delicate perspective; she suspects that issues are trying very dangerous, the American and Japanese husband and father of her son is not going to return to get better them; a suspicion or certainty that she insists on denying as a result of the greatness of tragedy consists in overcoming passive virtues equivalent to acceptance, forgiveness and resignation.

From all this it’s clear that what’s necessary right here is to symbolize the nakedness of intimacy, the purity of the struggling soul, whose surroundings doesn’t by itself clarify the depth of the drama. In Madrid, the Teatro de la Zarzuela hosted a Scottish Opera manufacturing in July 1991 (1987), with stage route by Nuria Espert, adorned Ezio Frigerio and collectible figurines of Franca Squarciapino that underlined the social context, in keeping with the time period of the time, relegating Cio Cio San's intimate diary to the chronicle of a prostitution neighborhood (which the filmmaker Mizogouchi The manufacturing of the Teatro Regio Torino, commissioned by the Teatro Real, exacerbates this attitude, including distress, squalor, narrowness and vulgarity in a supposed try at social criticism. The whole starting is an amazing barrage of descriptive photos that impoverish and cheapen the figures and their actions; poverty and cheapening that bogs down the story till the tip. So, the which means of the work is degraded, it doesn’t present itself. The scenario of the carnal commerce within the East is undoubtedly regrettable, however even sadder that a creative work is left jeopardized by what’s nothing greater than a prejudice that doesn’t even deserve the outline of “ideological.” The forceful closing boo to these chargeable for the staging reveals that the viewer is just not glad with the report and regrets the absence of the tragedy.

Puccini's work tries to outlive the Sunday newspaper report, however the catastrophe on stage inevitably influences each the orchestral route and the work of the performers. Saioa Hernández (Butterfly) and Silvia Beltrami (Suzuki), With little assist in costume and performing route, with creditable performances they reminded the general public of what that they had come to see. Mathew Polenzani, unfriendly and brutal like a Pinkerton surrounded by prostitutes whereas ready for his girlfriend, fails to make his closing pretend repentance plausible. Lucas Meachem is an typically inaudible Sharpless. Mikeldi Atxanlandaso He is an efficient singer and an exquisite actor; The Goro that has been imposed on him is unnecessarily naughty. The baton of Luca Luisotti she appeared contaminated by the aggressive boredom that fell from the stage; the orchestra is able to nuances and intensities that on this case didn’t fairly emerge, smothered by a sleepy languor. That the general public didn’t obtain, or didn’t need to see, decided, with all purpose, to get better considered one of his most lovingly treasured works. The program celebrated different performances with legendary performers who this time haven’t been, if not resurrected, and even evoked.

Three different casts will take turns within the following performances, with the inevitable variations in suitability and success in every case, though everybody will do kind of the identical factor that has needed to be endured the opening evening.

An finish of the season one thing disconcerting, a symptom of how opera lives, and the way it’s lived in the present day.


https://www.elmundo.es/cultura/musica/2024/06/30/6681cbf1fc6c83a64d8b457d.html