UniCredit-Commerzbank: the pleasant merger does not take off, it is time to consider a plan B | EUROtoday

Listen to the audio model of the article

It could also be that within the coming weeks the German reception to the speculation of an aggregation between UniCredit and Commerzbank will change and turn into extra open-minded. For now it does not look like we’re getting in that path. Indeed, day by day new indicators emerge of clear opposition to the opening of a “friendly” negotiation as UniCredit would really like. The German Government, or reasonably the Chancellery places of work led by the social democrat Olaf Scholz, regardless of not having official veto powers, continues to covertly increase the barricades in opposition to the operation. A selection that can be political and electoral – in Germany we are going to vote in September 2025, if not earlier than – which takes into consideration the clear proclamations in opposition to the Italian acquisition of Commerz declared by the CDU (chief within the voting polls to the detriment of the SPD) .

The alerts

However, the speculation of a pleasant negotiation put ahead by UniCredit was initially addressed to the highest administration and stakeholders of Commerzbank. But even on this entrance the indicators appear something however encouraging. The former CEO Manfred Knof, who the day earlier than the acquisition of 9% by UniCredit had surprisingly introduced that he wished to stay on the helm of the financial institution for just one yr, was urgently changed after a couple of days by the previous CFO Bettina Orlopp who had beforehand at all times stated she was in opposition to any sort of aggregation for Commerzbank. It is just too early to say whether or not Orlopp is prepared to alter her thoughts and settle for the “friendly” desk proposed by UniCredit. From the primary strikes, it might appear the other. First she herself introduced a rise within the revenue targets of the stand-alone group, then yesterday the financial institution formally declared that on the capital market day in February it should current an replace of the stand-alone technique. And lastly yesterday, in an interview with a German newspaper, Orlopp herself declared that Commerzbank is evaluating acquisitions to develop independently, beginning with asset administration.

Negotiation ways or barricades

Negotiating tactic to lift the value and situations of a attainable aggregation with UniCredit, ranging from the extremely coveted registered workplace of the mixed entity? Or escalation of indicators of complete barricades in opposition to the Italian try to “amicably” combination Commerz? In the world of funding banking, the second speculation is taken into account probably the most credible. But the opposition from the financial institution and German politics doesn’t imply UniCredit’s retreat is the primary selection. On the opposite. The Italian group, additionally due to purchases booked by means of spinoff devices, has already probably risen to 21% of Commerz’s capital and enjoys the favor of institutional buyers who personal the vast majority of the German financial institution’s capital.

Also in favor of the aggregation is the ECB Supervision, which for years has been supporting cross-border mergers, in addition to a major a part of Bavarian entrepreneurs who’ve been prospects of the German financial institution (previously HVB) owned by UniCredit for years. And definitely so is the EU Commission, which for years has been working to create European champions of finance and business. There are due to this fact numerous situations for the tried acquisition of Commerz by UniCredit to remodel from “friendly” into one thing completely different within the coming weeks. A hostile operation? The funding bankers of the town of London choose to talk of “unsolicited offers”. Easy to say so long as you maneuver inside home borders, extra problematic when the goal firm is situated in one other giant European nation. UniCredit at this stage has the assets to do it, we must see if it additionally has the braveness.