When France destroys its reminiscence | EUROtoday
Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.
Iten years in the past, Régis Debray revealed The Calculation Error. A response to the Prime Minister on the time, Manuel Valls, who declared on the Medef summer season universities: “I like the corporate. » The author was extra usually indignant on the State’s submission to the coverage of figures in all issues, together with cultural and heritage issues.
He wasn’t flawed. The controversy referring to the removing of November 11 as a public vacation is a part of this decadence of public energy. And Michel Barnier has already made historical past by refusing to subscribe to this antics.
Why hassle with flags?
Remove a vacation that nobody cares about to generate profits. This is why November 11 needs to be, in keeping with some, “worked”. Let us take this argument severely within the time of a textual content to disclose its absurdity. It just isn’t solely an assault towards the symbolic order of the Republic, it’s an assault towards the symbolic order tout court docket. Or, to place it higher, towards the usefulness of symbols.
Doing and not using a public vacation as a result of it brings in cash quantities to asserting the prevalence of an Excel desk over the figurative universe. A reasoning not devoid of embellishment, however, effectively, let’s admit it. If the Republic solely wants cash, why hassle with flags, the Republican Guard, processions, firm automobiles, pink carpets, July 14, briefly with the heavy and, furthermore, expensive protocol of the state?
If the fluff of public energy is ineffective, we’d as effectively get rid of it instantly. We could be the primary nation on the planet to think about that it’s self-sufficient to proceed. Coming from France, which has by no means been sober on this matter, this could not lack taste. If Louis XIV heard that…
“At least don’t do it again.”
Even extra severe, this concept is ignorance. The financial energy and affect of France should not coupled. This is a lesson from historical past: fame and development charges are totally different topics.
For instance, the state was by no means as reformed as underneath the Consulate of Napoleon Bonaparte (1799-1804), at a time when France was not notoriously affluent. It even emerged from its final cost default in 1798. Assuming that it considerations a rustic which lives by brilliance, panache and its repute, the financial argument doesn’t maintain up.
What concerning the level of a public vacation, and the ethical facet hooked up to it? Should we, because the Prime Minister suggests, respect the reminiscence of the fighters who died for France? Asking this query is already insolence.
But let’s admit, as soon as once more, that we do with out it. The Republic could be ungrateful. After having despatched hundreds of thousands of French folks to be killed in its title, it could right now take away from them the one factor they gained there, their final cost, not glory, however the testimony of a bloodbath whose solely usefulness is that it not reproduces.
If the First World War was nicknamed the “Der des Der”, it was as a result of it had not left good reminiscences and the primary want of a combatant, even when he was lifeless, was to not see his youngsters undergo the identical factor. Dead, due to this fact, with out having the proper to say: “At least, don’t do it again.” »
As for the message despatched to the youthful generations, who, someday or one other, may need to struggle for this summary factor referred to as France, it’s deleterious to say the least. They are assured upfront ingratitude and oblivion. That would not make you wish to be patriotic.
Commemoration supplants trauma
Finally, it is dangerous manners for the households of the furry ones. As Stéphane Audoin-Rouzeau and Annette Becker confirmed in 14-18, rediscover the battlethe State disadvantaged households of the mourning of their deceased. Memorials to the lifeless, public ceremonies, nationwide tributes have been helpful to the homeland, however they prevented widows, youngsters, mother and father from taking possession of the demise of the family members they’d misplaced.
After having devoured its youngsters, the State additionally demanded to digest them. “In the name of the “duty of memory”” there has arisen a “frequent forgetting of the “duty of History””. Commemoration supplants trauma. Individual tragedies have been ordered to vanish behind nationwide curiosity.
To Discover
Kangaroo of the day
Answer
Incapable of assuming its sovereign features, anachronistic in its strategies and its functioning, the State is a day by day handicap, to not say a plague. France is within the technique of feudalization and the fragmentation of its forces is worsening every day.
After many years of deleterious administration, the Republic can not destroy the final of its redoubts, its historical past and its reminiscence. Without that, nothing will stay, and the French will depart, with out even trying again, with out even remembering that the floating shadow underneath which they’d lived had as soon as been a nation.
https://www.lepoint.fr/societe/quand-la-france-detruit-sa-memoire-12-11-2024-2575146_23.php