Lucy Letby newest: Nurse didn’t homicide any infants, claims professional, as unhealthy care and pure causes blamed | EUROtoday
Lucy Letby didn’t homicide seven infants at Countess of Chester Hospital, declare consultants, who say recent medical proof reveals pure causes and “bad medical care” had been guilty.
A panel of worldwide consultants introduced “significant new medical evidence” within the case of the convicted killer on Tuesday morning.
Letby is serving 15 whole-life orders for the homicide of seven infants and tried homicide of seven others between June 2015 and June 2016 on the Countess of Chester Hospital.
Dr Shoo Lee, a Canadian neonatologist whose work was cited by the prosecution within the authentic trial, mentioned a crew of 14 neonatologists had reviewed every of the instances, discovering flaws within the prosecution’s proof.
He mentioned: “In summary, ladies and gentleman, we did not find any murders. In all cases death or injury were deemed to be natural causes or just bad medical care.”
It comes as Letby’s legal professionals utilized for her case to be reviewed by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) as a possible miscarriage of justice.
Letby’s lawyer, Mark McDonald, mentioned: “What we have just heard and what will be in the report is overwhelming evidence that this conviction is unsafe and must be urgently referred back to the Court of Appeal.”
‘It is a few younger girl’s life’, Dr Shoo Lee explains why he took investigation on
Dr Shoo Lee mentioned he took on the Lucy Letby investigation as a result of he “could not see how we could send an innocent woman to jail for the rest of her life if in fact she was innocent”.
Speaking after the press convention, he mentioned that he was first contacted in regards to the case in relation to an enchantment by the convicted little one killer and, after taking a look at transcripts, he grew to become “concerned that there was a problem with this conviction because the evidence that’s being used to convict her – regardless of whether she is innocent or guilty – was wrong”.
He later added: “It is about a young woman’s life. All of us, our lives are precious. I could not see how we could send an innocent woman to jail for the rest of her life if in fact she was innocent.
“So I decided to investigate and that’s when I approached the solicitors to say I would be willing to look at the evidence to see whether or not there was a problem with the evidence.
“This is no longer just one physician standing up to say Lucy Letby was wrongly accused, this is the panel of 14 of the world’s top experts.
“If you don’t believe them who will you believe?”

Alex Ross4 February 2025 13:05
Letby’s lawyer needs case referred to the Court of Appeal by the summer time
Mark McDonald, the barrister main Lucy Letby’s authorized crew has described Tuesday’s presentation as a “gamechanger”.
Asked what he considered the press convention, Mr McDonald mentioned: “I’ve never known anything like it.
“You know, never before – and I mean it’s a grand statement to make – but never before have we had such an experienced credible body of experts come together across the world and say something has gone wrong, and I think it’s a gamechanger.”
Mr McDonald mentioned he want to see the matter “certainly referred to the Court of Appeal by the summer”.
Downing Street declines to touch upon utility for Letby case to be reviewed
Downing Street declined to touch upon an utility by convicted little one serial killer Lucy Letby to have her case reviewed.
Asked whether or not Sir Keir Starmer thought she was responsible, the Prime Minister’s official spokesman mentioned: “This was a truly horrendous case that shocked the nation. A criminal trial has taken place and Lucy Letby was found guilty.
“There is, of course, an established process through the Criminal Cases Review Commission, which is independent of Government, and the commission has today confirmed they have received an application from Ms Letby’s legal team.
“We wouldn’t get drawn on that independent process.”
Alex Ross4 February 2025 12:34
What occurs now?
Despite the bombshell press convention, the place a panel of main neonatologists mentioned they imagine all Letby’s victims died of pure causes or unhealthy medical care, Letby continues to be a convicted little one assassin.
Having been sentenced to fifteen complete life orders, she is going to by no means be launched except her bid to overturn her convictions succeeds.
The panel’s findings will now be handed to the Criminal Cases Review Commission who should resolve if the brand new proof deserves the case being referred to the Court of Appeal.
But with a prolonged backlog, it may take years for them to analyze her case and there’s no assure they are going to agree together with her lawyer’s evaluation that the proof in opposition to her has been “demolished”.
If the CCRC utility succeeds, it can then be as much as judges on the Court of Appeal to evaluation her conviction.

Amy-Clare Martin4 February 2025 12:22
Medical professional’s conclusions in 4 factors
The press convention has ended and a report on the medical crew’s proof has been given to journalists.
Here is the conclusion summarised in 4 factors:
- There was no medical proof to help malfeasance inflicting loss of life or damage in any of the 17 instances within the trial
- Death of damage of affected infants had been on account of pure causes or errors in medical care
- There had been issues associated to the medical care of sufferers on the Countess of Chester Hospital neonatal unit
- There had been issues associated to teamwork and inter-disciplinary collaboration of the Countess of Chester Hospital neonatal unit
Alex Ross4 February 2025 12:17
‘Overwhelming proof conviction is unsafe’, says Letby’s lawyer
Mark McDonald, the barrister main Lucy Letby’s authorized crew mentioned they might be again within the Court of Appeal “very soon”.
It comes after an utility was made by the crew to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) for a evaluation of the convictions on the grounds of a possible miscarriage of justice.
Mr McDonald mentioned: “There is overwhelming evidence that the conviction is unsafe. And if Dr Shoo Lee and the panel are correct, no crime was committed.
“And if no crime was committed, that means a 34-year-old woman is currently sitting in prison for the rest of her life for a crime that just never happened.”
Alex Ross4 February 2025 11:58
Medical proof in opposition to Letby has been ‘demolished’, lawyer claims
Asked in regards to the different circumstantial proof introduced by the prosecution in opposition to Letby, Mr McDonald mentioned: “The reason why Lucy Letby was convicted was because of the medical evidence that was presented to the jury. That today has been demolished.”
Sir David added that the statistical proof has additionally been demolished.
Amy-Clare Martin4 February 2025 11:51
‘If this was a hospital in Canada, it might be shut down’, says Dr Lee
Asked in regards to the Countess of Chester Hospital throughout questions from journalists on the Lucy Letby press convention, Dr Shoo Lee, a retired medic from Canada, mentioned: “I would say if this was a hospital in Canada, it would be shut down.
“It would not be happening.”

Alex Ross4 February 2025 11:49
Lawyer says consultants report is ‘overwhelming evidence that this conviction is unsafe’
Letby’s barrister Mark McDonald mentioned they’ve made an utility to the Criminal Cases Review Commission who’re “waiting eagerly” for the consultants’ report.
“What we have just heard and what will be in the report is overwhelming evidence that this conviction is unsafe and must be urgently referred back to the Court of Appeal,” he mentioned.

Amy-Clare Martin4 February 2025 11:41
Sir David Davis says it is a ‘case study’ in why courts should overhaul how they deal with professional proof
“Back in 2011 the Law Commission published a report challenging the handling of expert evidence in court,” MP Sir David Davis says.
“This case is a case study in why that report should have been implemented. It hasn’t been and it should be now.”
He’s referred to as for an overhaul of how “new evidence” is outlined for the needs of an enchantment.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lucy-letby-trial-new-evidence-guilty-nurse-b2691730.html