A instructor on the defendant bench | EUROtoday

On Mar 10, 2025

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.

DIt is Evaëlle modified faculty in March, her mom has the impression that she is best. The finish of the yr is approaching and the Dupuis household is delighted to go and go to the Futuroscope quickly. Marie, Evaëlle’s mom, remembers the week previous on June 21, 2019. She was “normal”, “without conflict”, “or particular struggle”, she stated. The driver of the bus who brings again the 11 -year -old faculty pupil daily, nevertheless, famous a change of temper in Evaëlle, whom he describes as “smart” and extra “advanced” than youngsters of her age. The little lady had as soon as advised her to be “bothered” by teenagers from the school.

For the previous few days, the driving force has observed that Evaëlle has not sowed subsequent to him, as she is used to it. He even requested her if she made her head. Eyes riveted on her telephone, she replied that no, that she simply did not need to discuss. This June 21, when Evaëlle returned dwelling round 4:30 p.m., her mom discovered her calm. It is by going to see her in her room an hour and a half later that she discovers the pages of her torn correspondence ebook.

His daughter explains to him to be indignant as a result of a comrade emptied his schoolbag and threw his issues on the bottom after a dispute. Marie Dupuis cracks, fists on the door, tells her daughter that she ought to have warned an grownup and leaves the room in a sob. When Sébastien Dupuis comes again from work somewhat later, his spouse warns him: “Ascended, there was still a problem. The father opens the door of the room and discovers his daughter hanging from a scarf hanging on the bed-mazzanine.

“I’m so used to it that I now not react”

Evaëlle had returned to sixth in the Isabelle-Autissier college, in Herblay, in Val-d’Oise, in September 2018. The year was pretty good, until November and an English presentation at the end of which Evaëlle obtained half a point than her friends for good pronunciation. His mother, who lived in the United States, wrote the words in phonetics on a sheet. His comrades accuse him of having done nothing and calls her “dishonest”. There follows a letter in which the little girls explain to Evaëlle that they will no longer be her friends. A few weeks later, Evaëlle tried to set fire to the family home, which her parents will interpret as a suicide attempt.

At the end of November 2018, the parents of the college student learn that, beyond childish bickering, their daughter is the target of bullying from several students. A group of boys insult him regularly, makes him hook and her hair, laughs at his hair. Around the winter holidays, things get worse to the point that Evaëlle’s parents decide to file a harassment complaint against several of them. In front of the police, Evaëlle recounts two incidents that occurred in February. The first takes place at the end of college: while waiting for the bus, a boy pushes her to the ground. The vehicle can be avoided shortly, his glasses break. Evaëlle and the boy exchange slaps.

There is also this episode in the playground. One day when she was lying on a bench, another boy came to push her, dropping her on the ground three times. “I didn’t communicate of all these insults and these gestures to an grownup in faculty as a result of I’m so used to that now I don’t react anymore, I don’t reply them, as a result of, anyway, I’ve already tried and it doesn’t change something,” the little girl will tell the investigators.

“Worse day of my life”

Then there are also these difficulties with the French professor, Mrs. L. After an ankle injury, the doctor had suggested to Evaëlle to use a binder rather than notebooks in each subject. All teachers seem to have accepted the measure, except Ms. L., which requires a personalized support plan. According to Marie Dupuis, her daughter is also taken to the subject on the subject at the start of the course. Sitting at the bottom of the class despite her vision problems, the professor would have repeatedly refused to change Evaëlle de Place. Parents will make a first report to the principal of the college in December, without it being followed by effect.

Another event comes in February. During a pool outing, students who used to attack Evaëlle accuse him of having stolen a sock. After which the class is in French. In front of the dissipated assembly, Mrs. L., decides to do an hour of “class life” to understand why Evaëlle could feel “harassed and excluded”. To investigators, the little girl explains that she had experienced this moment as “a shock query”.

While the teacher the sum of explaining why she feels harassed, Evaëlle tries to answer, gets her liar and begins to cry. “She requested me to cease crying badly,” said Evaëlle. Coming back from school, she tells her mother that she had spent “the worst day of her life”. “The teacher asked us what was wrong and what bored us at Evaëlle. She got angry with her because she was crying, ”confirms a student.

The parents of Évaëlle decide to change her college

Heard by the investigators, Ms. L. explains for her part to have established a “second of sophistication life” where everyone could express themselves as they wish. Having learned that several children no longer wanted to speak or put themselves next to Evaëlle, she justifies this educational moment as a means of explaining to them that the attitude towards their comrade is not correct and that all must learn to live together.

After this particularly trying day for their daughter, Evaëlle’s parents are asking to meet the principal and announce that she will no longer assist in French until further notice. Her comrades deal with “fraudous” and “delinquent”. One day, of sadness and rage, Evaëlle goes so far as to cut her hair herself. Comes the episode of the bench. The drop of too much for the parents of the middle school, who decide to change her establishment.

The academic inspection is seized of the facts concerning the French professor. On March 11, 2019, Evaëlle returned to Georges-Duhamel college, located 800 meters from the previous one. If rumors of harassment accompany Evaëlle to her new establishment, the little girl still seems to feel better. But it only lasts a time. The little girl has the feeling of being harassed again. Until this terrible June 21 and the dispute with her classmate.

A teacher lasts with students in difficulty?

After the little girl’s suicide, an investigation is open. Very quickly, the languages will untie the subject of Mrs. L. Number of former students say that the professor has “her darlings”, always the elements with a strong personality, a lot of character and that she tends to make more fragile students of the scapegoats, not hesitating to take them to task in front of the whole class.

A former student of Ms. L. confirms that she was hard with students in difficulty: “Those who didn’t perceive sure workouts, they stated they had been morons. It additionally seems that in April 2019 a number of third college students wrote a letter entitled “Letter of remarks concerning Ms. L.”, transmitted to the CPE. In the missive, we are able to for instance learn: “Mrs. L. pushes students to the end, she has inappropriate words, insists on our shortcomings, laughs regularly …”

These repeated acts and phrases have undoubtedly brought on a deterioration in residing circumstances altering the well being of the lady.Instructor

Among the instructing workers, testimonies in direction of him are shared. Some declare that it’s a good colleague, who was doing his job with accuracy, which may increase the tone with out decreasing. Others, quite the opposite, admitted to worry it and even entrusted that she had made sure lecturers cry. In September 2020, Ms. L. will likely be indicted of the chief of “15 -year -old minor harassment”. The investigating choose thought-about that Evaëlle had been the goal of “many reflections”, showing to be “lower and unjustified” on the a part of the instructor. “These repeated acts and words have undoubtedly caused a deterioration in living conditions altering the health of the girl,” notes the Justice of the Peace in her referral order.

A professor on the defendant bench

During the investigation, two different former college students will even be a civil get together, in flip accusing the harassment professor. The trial of Ms. L. have to be held on Monday March 10 and Tuesday March 11 earlier than the Pontoise Criminal Court. The instructor, who had continued to offer her college the varsity yr in response to the suicide of Evaëlle, will finally be prohibited to train in September 2020, a measure linked to her judicial management. 62 years outdated, she faces two years in jail.

“The unprecedented nature of this case is to have a professor on the defendant’s bench. Long underestimated, harassment has been highlighted recently but only between students, ”underlines M^e Delphine Meillet, lawyer for the Dupuis household. According to the lawyer, Evaëlle’s mother and father consider that it was the professor who sparked the good misery of their daughter. “For them, by behaving badly with Evaëlle, Ms. L. gave authorization to other students to take over,” says Mr.^e Meillet, recalling that the professor is an authority.

To uncover

The kangaroo of the day

Answer

“What happened is an ineffable drama and if my client feels the biggest compassion for the family, she considers, on the other hand, that she has never committed malicious acts with regard to Evaëlle, nor of any other child,” stated M.^e Marie Roumianteva, the lawyer for Mrs. L., the latter specifies that, in 33 years of profession, Ms. L. had 1000’s of scholars in progress, on the fee of 120 to 140 per yr. “Of the six academic inspections in which she has been the subject, it has always emerged from this that she supervised her students very well,” stated M^e Roumantseva, who talks a few extreme instructor, after all, however not inflexible.

M^e Roumianteva regrets that all through the 2018-2019 college yr, the mother and father of Evaëlle, who had been joyful to talk of their daughter’s “precocity”-without being based mostly on any standardized test-, nevertheless, didn’t point out the difficulties she may encounter. M^eMeillet, the lawyer for Evaëlle’s mother and father, acknowledges that it was a “fragile” baby. “Nevertheless, it is not a little one who was in the revolt, against the authority,” says Mr.^e Meillet. Regarding the information of harassment, a number of different college students had been additionally implicated. Two of them had been lastly referred to the tribunal for kids and positioned underneath judicial supervision pending their trial.

https://www.lepoint.fr/societe/suicide-d-evaelle-11-ans-une-enseignante-sur-le-banc-des-prevenus-10-03-2025-2584290_23.php