Science dismantles the parable of the ‘murderous shark’: most bites are a self -defense reflection | Science | EUROtoday
For a long time they’ve been portrayed as serial murderers. The dangerous repute of sharks is disproportionate in relation to the variety of assaults that perpetrate in opposition to people. About 100 bites are often registered a 12 months world wide and 10% of them are mortal. A stage very totally different from what the legendary film portrays Sharkof 1975, which fed an unfair stigma that crawls to the current. Fearful of most individuals, the reality is that this nice fish that strikes by way of the ocean in a sigril, shy and infrequently searching in herd, not solely bites by defending their territory and competing with their friends. The survival intuition is one other further issue: they’re these dentellated in professional protection linked to an earlier motion dedicated by a human, which the animal interprets as an aggression.
This is learn within the research led by Eric E. Clua, a researcher on the Paris Sciences and Letters University, which is revealed this Friday. This new evaluation, which compares world observations and others made in French Polynesia for its plentiful marine life, highlights this little studied variable attributable to the shark chunk: self -defense. The accidents are superficial as a result of the animal doesn’t search meals, however its personal safety: it isn’t deadly, though violent. Bites in quest of meals are characterised by a big extraction of meat and excessive mortality attributable to bleeding. “Whether intentionally or not, people are responsible for these bites. Even for the simple fact of being at sea, which is the kingdom of sharks,” Clua explains to El País.
Although defensive conduct has been noticed in massive birds as casuales and land mammals as bears, it has not been documented intimately with scenaries. For this, the researchers in contrast shark bites of the database of the worldwide shark assaults, with some 7,000 bites recorded since 1863. They targeted on bites associated to actions that would convey folks nearer to sharks – underwater fishing and others wherein they penetrate their territory – and that differentiated between provoked and never brought on.
The findings, revealed within the journal Frontiers in Conservation ScienceThey point out {that a} complete of 322 bites that occurred on this planet might have been motivated by self -defense, with a price of lethality of three.2%. They are primarily inflicted by species of medium -sized coastal sharks (lower than 3 meters lengthy), comparable to black suggestions shark (Carcharhinus melanopterus) or the grey shark (Carcharhinus plumbeus).
In the Polynesian archipelago of 118 islands, shark bites have been registered since 1940. However, the information of the Insular Research Center and Observatory of the Environment that embrace dependable info started later: between 2009 and 2023. During these 15 years 74 dentelladas had been documented, 4 of them in self -defense, which exhibits a prevalence of 5%.
In French Polynesia there are actions that trigger this self -defense conduct, comparable to fishing with Almadraba (to seize purple tuna) and fishing with harpoon (which is carried out with a hook), which aren’t normal somewhere else. But additionally one other kind of fishing, comparable to leisure – very talked-about in international locations such because the US and Australia – can increase these bites, so “the comparison is legitimate but indirect,” provides the primary writer of the investigation. Collecting this information on a world scale precisely continues to be tough.
Certain species of benthic sharks (comparable to carpet shark, in Australia) can react instinctively when folks stroll on them unintentious as a result of they have an inclination to perch on the sand comparable to stripes. “It is advisable not to go to the aid of a shark in danger, since it will not necessarily perceive this human action,” says the professional.
None of the analyzed bites was preceded by irregular shark agonistic conduct (whose function is to hurt one other), comparable to decreasing the chest or swimming hunched. Scientists within the research query the apply of labeling all self -defense bites “as attacks.”
Among essentially the most threatened animals
For some cultures, as in Polynesia, sharks are thought of sacred animals or Drug-totem and Guardians of the Islands. They are navigators who’ve an essential position in folks’s lives and tradition. This perspective has traditionally restricted its exploitation in that a part of the world.
Sharks in Polynesia are protected, though native fishermen don’t at all times respect this regulation. In basic, island traditions combine nature and tradition, linking the religious and human world. It is alleged that every one marine parts are descendants of the god Tangaroawhich allowed the primary life within the atolls, islands within the type of ring sunk within the ocean and surrounded by coral reefs.
And regardless of the rising world safety measures, they embrace among the many most threatened animals on this planet. The causes are a number of: the demand of its fins is a really profitable enterprise in Asia, added to the incidental seize and the rising market of shark meat that has produced the demise of hundreds of thousands of those animals.
https://elpais.com/ciencia/2025-04-25/la-ciencia-desmonta-el-mito-del-tiburon-asesino-la-mayoria-de-las-mordeduras-son-un-reflejo-de-autodefensa.html