After Nogent’s drama, the (false) good concepts of the manager to finish violence amongst younger folks | EUROtoday

French News

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.


MArdi June 10, a 31-year-old schooling assistant, mom of a 4-year-old baby, was killed with a number of stab wounds by a 14-year-old scholar on the entrance to a school in Nogent, Haute-Marne. “He did not have a particular grievance” towards the sufferer and “specifies that he did so because he no longer supported the behavior of the supervisors in general, who, according to him, would have had a different attitude according to the students,” stated the Public Prosecutor of Chaumont, Denis Devallois on Wednesday, June 11, at a press convention.

Evening level

Every night from 6 p.m.

Receive the data analyzed and deciphered by writing the purpose.

THANKS !
Your registration has been taken into consideration with the e-mail handle:

To uncover all of our different newsletters, go right here: my account

By registering, you settle for the final circumstances of use and our privateness coverage.

This drama is sadly rarer in newspapers. Thursday, April 24, a scholar from a Catholic highschool in Nantes had killed a comrade and injured three others with a knife. Last January, Elias, a 14 -year -old teenager, succumbed to a machete given in Paris by a 16 -year -old boy. In February 2023 in Saint-Jean-de-Luz, a university scholar stabbed his instructor, Agnès Lassalle.

The horror of the info, their recurrence and the stirred have compelled politicians to react. But how you can safe 9,800 faculties and excessive colleges (private and non-private), when nothing – neither the kind of highschool, nor the social surroundings of the aggressor, nor his motivations – appears to convey these dramas nearer?

Weapon detection gantries on the entrance to institutions, video surveillance, random excavations, ban on the sale of white weapons to minors, protocol for figuring out and taking good care of college students with psychological issues, ban on social networks … The day turned to the Lépine competitors, however for what effectivity? Review of arguments and counter-arguments.

Weapon detection gantries on the entrance to institutions

François Bayrou stated he wished to experiment these detection gadgets, “like what we have in airports”. With the intention of “spreading in the minds of all students and their parents the idea that the knife is prohibited because it is dangerous, including for those who wear it”.

But the measure, advocated in 2009 by the Minister of National Education Xavier Darcos, is deemed costly and never very credible by the academic group, which factors to the queues that this might create on the entrance to institutions.

“In the establishment where I previously practiced, a system of Badge turnstiles had been set up. These were not security gantries, but a simple system for regulating inputs and outputs. For an establishment of 1,500 students, this did not allow a fluid entrance in the morning: the large portal had to be open and guaranteed human surveillance, otherwise the students arrived late in progress. The device therefore served only the rest of the day, when the crowd is less, “says Mireille Chovet, a principal of a-school city in Boën-sur-Lignon, in the Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes region, where the turnstiles were generalized in 2017 in the post-client context. The goal was then to avoid abusive intrusions in establishments. But the latter are useless to prevent the intrusion of white weapons.

“The installation of detection gates would ask the same fluidity questions at the entrance to high schools for a zero benefit. Because for a supervisor to detect a knife in a bag, he is not a security agent, he is not allowed to search in the bags. It would therefore be also necessary to recruit in addition to security agents, ”says Grégory collectively, nationwide vice-president of the Federation of Parents’ Councils (FCPE). Above all, he says, “adolescents will all the time discover a strategy to bypass these security gantries, passing a stabbing weapon by way of a grid or over a wall. “And then, we can also pass ceramic knives”, specifies Gérard Heinz, member of the SNPDEN UNSA union and principal of a flexible highschool in Belleville-en-Beaujolais. An argument additionally superior by the Minister of the Interior, Bruno Retailleau.

Video surveillance

Suggested by the deputy (horizons) and vice-president of the meeting, Naïma Moutchou, in a report submitted on the finish of May to François Bayrou, the set up of a scientific video surveillance seems simply as costly, even ineffective. “There are some in some institutions, however these photographs are solely exploited when there was an issue. Never upstream, as a result of it could require having a everlasting surveillance agent, paid by native communities. »»

Prohibition of the sale of white weapons to minors

Another suggestion of the Naïma Moutchou report: the ban on the sale of white weapons to minors. This must be made by a decree “within 15 days,” the federal government introduced on Wednesday. For the time being, a minor isn’t allowed to purchase warfare materials, ammunition and weapons of all classes, together with white weapons outlined as “any weapon whose piercing, sharp or brising action is only due to human strength”. Among them: daggers, opinels, Swiss knives or cutters.

The regulation doesn’t say something however on the kitchen knives. It is that this particular level that François Bayrou needs to make clear, by widening the ban on all knives. How will or not it’s checked? In retailer, on the request of identification papers. On the Internet, an grownup must signal the reception of a knife purchased on the Internet, stated the Prime Minister, who additionally added yesterday on TF1, that this must be strictly “controlled”.

Because the regulation is already very clear on the topic: whether or not one is a minor or main, it’s certainly prohibited to go away house with a knife. In the occasion of management, you should have the ability to give a professional motive, resembling going to a picnic or looking. Wanting to defend oneself towards a doable aggression isn’t a professional motive in itself. Minors danger three years’ imprisonment and a fantastic of 45,000 euros if they carry a knife or any sharp object in a college. These have to be accomplished with extra excavations, additionally recalled the Prime Minister.

Random excavations

These measures have already been put in place on the request of the Minister of Education, Élisabeth Borne, following the dying of a 15 -year -old teenager after the Nantes assault in April. Excavations close to the institutions have been arrange, within the presence of police, with a sure effectivity: between March 26 and May 23, 6,002 operations (for 12,000 faculties and excessive colleges) have been devoted to it. Nearly 300 weapons have been seized, together with 186 knives. These excavations led to 32 police custody and 567 disciplinary recommendation for knife detention. The truth stays that it was throughout considered one of these checks that the Nogent supervisor was killed.

Prohibition of social networks

The minister additionally argued “the generalization of the digital break”. “The excessive use of screens and social networks” which, in accordance with her, which might “lead to violent, somewhat derealized behaviors” on the a part of younger folks, she stated throughout her journey.

The day earlier than on LCI, she had additionally introduced the potential for distributing from the 4th grade of the extracts from the miniseries Adolescence. “Very representative of violence which can exist in young people”, they intention to boost consciousness of scholars “to the trivialization of violence on social networks” in addition to that of the propagation of misogynist and masculinist theses, she argued.

Emmanuel Macron has introduced that he’ll prohibit social networks to kids underneath the age of 15 if, in “a few months”, if this isn’t completed at European stage. “We cannot wait,” he stated, with out specifying the strategy.

Identifying and taking good care of younger folks with psychological well being issues

Make the hyperlink with the psychological well being issues of younger folks, the Minister of National Education additionally requested for the implementation of a “protocol for identifying and taking care of young people who can have psychological or psychiatric problems”. How ? Here once more, the academic group stays skeptical, which highlights the dearth of human monetary means.

What about psychological well being?


To uncover



The kangaroo of the day

Answer



“Currently, there is a doctor for 13,000 students, a nurse for 1,300 students and a psychologist for 1,500 students and the balance sheets as follows from the students are difficult to set up,” says Grégoire Entel. As for the administration of detected college students, it’s virtually nonexistent, the latter referring to well being personnel and medical-psychological facilities (CMP) already overwhelmed.

We are speaking about 100,000 euros every for a portico for the detection of weapons on the entrance to the institutions, sighs the nationwide vice-president of the Federation of Parents’ Councils (FCPE). “Wouldn’t we higher put this cash within the recruitment of extra instructional employees: docs, psychologists, college nurses, supervisors, senior schooling advisor (CPE) and in psychological well being usually? »»


https://www.lepoint.fr/education/apres-le-drame-de-nogent-les-fausses-bonnes-idees-de-l-executif-pour-mettre-fin-aux-violences-chez-les-jeunes-11-06-2025-2591822_3584.php

You might also like More from author