Flash of lucidity earlier than dying: the controversy that agitates neuroscience | Health and properly -being | EUROtoday
“My mother had an advanced Alzheimer’s. He no longer recognized us and seemed indifferent to those strangers who visited her once or twice a week. The day before her death, however, everything changed. He not only recognized us, but wanted to know what had happened to each one in the last year.” The testimony of a German girl, collected in 2019 by Alexander Batthyán, director of the Viktor Frankl Institute in Vienna, exhibits a case of what has been baptized as terminal lucidity, a short return of the self in individuals who appeared to have disappeared a very long time earlier than due to mind accidents or Alzheimer’s.
In his guide El Umbral (Errata Naturae), just lately revealed in Castilian, Batthyány tells his analysis on this little studied phenomenon, recounting circumstances of relations and well being professionals who attend what looks as if a short lived resurrection of somebody who was misplaced. According to their estimates, as much as 6% of people that appear to have misplaced consciousness perpetually expertise it. In an interview with El País, the psychologist defends the curiosity of finding out these circumstances to grasp their that means. For him, they problem the present conception that the thoughts is barely an rising property of the mind and that when it’s broken, consciousness disappears perpetually.
For Batthyam, terminal lucidity questions “naive materialism” that relates capacities comparable to reminiscence or imaginative and prescient with concrete areas of the mind and requires open to the likelihood that there’s an impartial consciousness of the mind. “In normal conditions, perhaps the best model is the materialist, but when we approach the end, materialism no longer applies,” he says.
Terminal lucidity and experiences near loss of life could be a sign for folks like Batthyány that, along with the consciousness that arises from the mind and that disappears when it deteriorates, there’s one other protected, ethereal, hidden throughout our earthly life by the earlier one, however that resurfaces within the submit -term of life, lastly launched from the chains of matter. That would clarify the ultimate sparks of consciousness or the tales of people that revive after having been clinically useless. That gentle on the finish of the tunnel, the encounter with deceased family members, the sensation of dissolution of the ego and unity with the universe that transmits an indescribable peace and makes a lot of those that have the expertise lose the concern of loss of life and even lengthy for it.
For now, proof to assist these such bold hypotheses is scarce, and Batthyam himself acknowledges it. Most of his analysis, such because the one which offers with the experiences near loss of life, depends upon the gathering of retrospective circumstances, of witnesses who inform what occurred, one thing that, in scientific phrases, is proof of low high quality. In such extraordinary and unpredictable experiences, it’s tough to use standards of contemporary science as is measurable, reproducible and predictable.
From the reference examine of the Dutch heart specialist Pim van Lommel, revealed within the journal The Lancet In 2001, the sphere of analysis of the sort of phenomena has been dominated by individuals who favor a dualistic interpretation, which states that there’s a separate consciousness of the mind. This occurs, partially, as a result of the identical investigation of experiences near loss of life appeared extra like a process of collaborators of Fourth millennium than severe scientists. Now, there are additionally some standard scientists who’re beginning to work on this subject. This is the case of the Science Group of the University of Lieja, in Belgium. This yr, a crew of that group, headed by Charlotte Martial, revealed within the journal Nature Reviews Neurologyan article wherein they current a neuroscientist mannequin of experiences near loss of life.
The Neptune mannequin (acronym in English of neurophysiological and evolutionary-psychological concept to grasp the experiences near loss of life) states that these experiences are a waterfall of neurophysiological and psychological processes that start in important conditions. In these circumstances, oxygen deprivation or mind modifications trigger will increase in neurotransmitters comparable to serotonin and dopamine and enhance neuronal excitability in some mind areas. That could be behind the vivid sensations, the calm or the sensation of being abandoning the physique itself, traits of the experiences near loss of life (ECM). In addition, they suggest to border this physiological response throughout the evolutionary concept, as a device to face threats. More than solutions, this mannequin is a framework to lift rigorous experiments.
Martial considers that the area of the dualistic imaginative and prescient within the interpretation of the ECM is due, on the one hand, “that there is no rigorous and convincing scientific framework to explain those subjective, rich and intense experiences that appear at a time when we would not have expected that there would be awareness.” In addition, in current a long time there have been no giant -scale experiments to check a scientific mannequin of ECM.
The proponents of dualist theories of loss of life recommend that what’s seen throughout an ECM or within the final moments of lucidity are a window to a different world wherein the foundations of this apply. Those who reside these frictions with the hereafter telling them that they had been flooded with a sense of peace and concord with the universe, who noticed how they separated from their physique or that had been surrounded by a brilliant gentle. But, as Martial has verified, it’s not essential to be near loss of life to reside these experiences. Stimulation of particular components of the mind with intracranial electrodes can induce related experiences, identical to psychedelic substances. It additionally occurs with syncopes.
In a just lately revealed article, she and her crew studied 22 wholesome volunteers who induced syncopes themselves. During their transient fainting, 36% reported a subjective expertise that fulfilled the factors for an ECM in response to the dimensions created by psychiatrist Bruce Greyson to guage them. 88% had emotions of peace or pleasure, 50% feeling of pleasure, 100% felt how they separated from their physique and 50% believed to enter one other extra ethereal world. This experiment suggests, in response to Martial, that hypoxia performs an necessary function in ECM.
Martial cooperates with an experiment to check dualism, hiding indicators within the resuscitation room, invisible from the mattress, to examine if sufferers can see them. “So far there are no conclusive results,” says the researcher, who acknowledges that, with the know-how that’s, such because the electroencephalogram or magnetic resonance, the concept of whether or not there’s a supply of the totally different consciousness of the mind can’t be examined.
From Barcelona, promoted by the Incloby Foundation, the Luz Project, an eight -year examine to review ECM and their lengthy -term results is being carried out. The important goal of the work is to doc how folks’s life and values change after being resuscitated after cardiorespiratory arrest. He leads this Luján Comas mission, specialist in anesthesiology and resuscitation on the Vall d’Hebron hospital in Barcelona for 32 years: “They experience peace and love, and are able to see people who have died, many express that they felt they arrived home and did not want to return to life”. “They return changed, with other values, more spiritual, although not necessarily religious, recognize what really makes sense in life, focusing on love,” says Comas.
The specialist believes that “if people have these experiences when the brain is flat and has no electrical activity, the concept that consciousness is only a product of the brain and ends when it stops working is not correct.” But he acknowledges that, for now, it’s only a speculation.
In that soar, in the hunt for scientific assist that harmonizes ancestral religious intuitions and motive, supporters of dualistic imaginative and prescient often use quantum physics. The surgeon Manuel Sans Segarra, well-known for affirming that he has scientific proof that there’s life after loss of life, often appeals to quantum as a basis to affirm that there’s an immortal supraconcience of which we’re all half. But quantum physics “cannot be used to explain these phenomena”, within the phrases of Alberto Casas, CSIC analysis professor on the Institute of theoretical Physics of Madrid. “The brain is a macroscopic system, where these quantum effects are diluted,” he concludes.
Einstein spoke of a distant ghostic motion and Comas believes that the phenomenon tells us that “everything is interconnected” and that there’s a non -local consciousness that isn’t anchored to a person mind. Casas explains that “to think that a brain can be connected to another by a kind of telepathy due to the intertwining, does not support.” “Moreover, although they could be intertwined, quantum physics itself implies that no significant information could be transmitted,” he rises.
Dualism supporters are in a rush to go additional. In half, as a result of the materialistic rationalization, even when it had been true, wouldn’t provide reduction within the face of the anguish of loss of life, and the religious gives it, whether or not or not it has an actual base. For commas, the story of those experiences “offers hope that life continues and provides hope to individuals who have misplaced a liked one […] that you’ll discover your self once more. “” I feel that’s sufficient, if that helps an individual to get better, why ought to we destroy it? “He asks.
Although it’s nonetheless one other hypothesis unimaginable to confirm, the statements of Batthyán and Comas match the evolutionary rationalization to the truth that experiences comparable to ECM or individuals who declare to have had vivid contacts with the past seem in all instances and in all human cultures of the planet. They assist reside. Those who defend the dualistic speculation recommend that this universality of the tales proves that the past just isn’t a hallucination brought on by neuronal gears. For now, evidences solely permit to make sure one factor: the necessity for consolation that the human being has is insatiable.
https://elpais.com/salud-y-bienestar/2025-06-15/destellos-de-lucidez-antes-de-morir-el-debate-que-agita-a-la-neurociencia.html