timing error for Minister of Agriculture Annie Genevard? | EUROtoday
Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.
LDecember 8, 2025 on the Rungis market, the Minister of Agriculture, Annie Genevardlaunched the Conferences of meals sovereignty scheduled as a part of the Losarga regulation (steerage regulation for meals sovereignty and the renewal of generations in agriculture) adopted in March 2025. When we seek the advice of the federal government web site alleged to inspire this umpteenth session, we be taught that “guaranteeing our food sovereignty means being able to produce in France enough healthy, quality food to feed all French people”. And the minister spoke of the “great food awakening” with a commerce steadiness in deficit of 350 million euros over the primary 9 months of the yr, whereas it was in surplus of 8 billion solely two years in the past.
It stays to be seen who this awakening is meant for, figuring out that the questionnaire permits us to decide on between the farmer, the actor within the meals chain (industrialist, distributor, restaurateur, and many others.), the citizen and the buyer… Then arrive the plain questions which ask whether or not we should produce wholesome, sustainable, various meals in France, have the ability to export, purchase at an reasonably priced value… In the method, the ministry asks us if we all know that fifty% hen and 35% fruit and greens are imported. But additionally what ought to farmers and the State do to strengthen our meals sovereignty. And so on, going by means of the origin of the product, the function of intermediaries and, after all, the act of buy.
What European accountability?
Once all of the containers have been correctly ticked, we should ask ourselves the place the fifteenth query has gone, the one which doesn’t seem anyplace: do farmers, producers, shoppers and even politicians want this type of session to know the place our meals sovereignty stands and how you can assure it? Do we’d like an infantilizing guessing recreation to know the issue and contemplate options? Solutions essentially correlated with buying energy whereas establishments not swear by indicators of high quality to which, paradoxically, many shoppers don’t or not have entry. Because clearly, the components may be summed up in just a few phrases: everybody needs to eat French merchandise so long as they will afford them!
In the identical column
ALSO READ Agriculture: placing an finish to “food sovereignty” At this stage of the dialogue comes the issue of the worth and the price of manufacturing which circumstances it with, to extend it, costs and requirements larger than these which imported manufacturing should bear. And right here we are able to cite, once more and amongst different bilateral agreements systematically co-signed by French Ministers of Agriculture for many years, the one which hyperlinks Morocco to our nation with imports of tomatoes which have gone, in a decade, from 240,000 tonnes per yr to greater than 450,000. A couple of extra years and, certainly – as a result of the workforce in Western Sahara doesn’t exceed 10 euros per day – the meals awakening for the vegetable sector will resonate extra in Agadir or Meknes than in Nantes, Châteaurenard, Perpignan or Marmande.
Ditto when Annie Genevard exonerates European nations from all accountability: “I’m not telling you that we have to be protectionist. France is not an island, it will also be necessary to rely on European imports. » We will therefore cite in this respect the Spanish peaches and nectarines sector which, in twenty years, went from 500,000 to 1.5 million tonnes while, at the same time, in France, this production plummeted from 400,000 to 200,000 tonnes.
ALSO READ CAP: Paris facing the risk of “27 agricultural policies” Same commentary in viticulture the place this emblematic manufacturing of the French terroir is threatened whereas our Italian rivals proceed to progress on the worldwide market and have turn into, with greater than 22 million hectoliters, the world’s main exporters. It needs to be famous that France imports greater than 6 million hectoliters (bulk and entry-level) primarily from Italy and Spain. Six million hectoliters, roughly what ought to not be produced in France in change for, for definitive uprooting, compensation of 4,000 euros per hectare which doesn’t even pay for the diesel, labor, share and chain to drag the stumps.
Citizen consultations and placebo devices
Most sectors of manufacturing, more and more diminished to their naked minimal, are incapable of preventing in opposition to the social drawback which now calibrates provide and demand on a world stage. Since Emmanuel Macron got here to energy, citizen consultations and different placebo devices have adopted each other from ministries to demonstrations. And nothing, completely nothing, has developed favorably within the meadows, within the fields, within the stables, within the vineyards and within the orchards. On the opposite, discontent has solely elevated amongst these farmers who, furthermore, are insulted as quickly as they harness an atomizer, a harvest bin, a rotovator, a slurry tanker.
ALSO READ Everything you might want to find out about lumpy pores and skin illnessWas one more session needed when the French countryside is confronted with lumpy pores and skin illness virusbilateral agreements with Mercosur, environmental dogmas and administrative constraints which influence the competitiveness of agricultural sectors? Pragmatic, the peasant world is resistant to what’s ineffective, to what wastes its time, to the speeches saved by retailers of reasoning, to the recommendation given by those that know nothing about their professions.
To Discover
Kangaroo of the day
Answer
Despite this, it’s nonetheless this career that we care for. For what ? Well, fairly merely – and Annie Genevard alluded to this by evoking the “agricultural war” and its “rearmament” – as a result of the peasant stays the one we search for when the cabinets are empty. Until the day when the farmer will not be there, as a result of those that run the nation can have most well-liked the geopolitics of concessions to the audacity of competitors.
Given the worldwide context, clearly the equation may be understood. But the results may be significantly attenuated if costs are diminished, if requirements are left apart a little bit, if administrative constraints are significantly diminished. To obtain this, there isn’t any have to “consult”, you simply want to look at what our rivals do every time they need to usurp our markets!
https://www.lepoint.fr/debats/grand-reveil-alimentaire-erreur-de-timing-pour-la-ministre-de-l-agriculture-annie-genevard-16-12-2025-2605436_2.php