4 indictments after clashes at Israel Orchestra live performance | EUROtoday
Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.
JThursday, November 6, the live performance of the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra, performed by Lahav Shani, was interrupted a number of instances on the Philharmonie de Paris. As the primary notes of the Piano Concerto No. 5 of Beethoven, a number of individuals shouted slogans hostile to Israel and threw leaflets into the group.
On movies posted on social networks, we are able to see that two smoke bombs had been lit within the room, inflicting panic among the many spectators. Clashes broke out between activists and the general public, earlier than the police intervened.
Around fifteen legislation enforcement autos had been deployed across the constructing. The live performance, suspended through the intervention, was in a position to resume after the evacuation of the disruptors. Four people had been arrested and positioned in police custody, indicated the Minister of the Interior, Laurent Nuñez. The Philharmonie de Paris condemned “serious incidents” in a press launch and introduced its intention to file a grievance, recalling that “nothing can justify endangering the safety of the public, staff and artists”.
A suspect listed S
According to info collected by BFMTV, the 4 suspects had been indicted on Sunday November 9 and positioned beneath judicial supervision. Three of them are being prosecuted for “endangering the lives of others”, whereas the fourth is suspected of getting organized an undeclared demonstration. The fees additionally embrace “damaging the property of others by dangerous means”, “possession of an incendiary product” and “violence with the use or threat of a weapon”.
Among these arrested was a 20-year-old man, listed as S for belonging to the “protest movement”, discovered with disruptive tools: stink balls, crimson ink and alarm. Another 31-year-old particular person, suspected of getting lit a smoke bomb, was arrested after being attacked by spectators. A 26-year-old lady, additionally suspected of setting off a smoke bomb, was carrying a number of pro-Palestinian leaflets. The fourth accused, at the moment being questioned, is suspected of getting coordinated the motion.
A live performance on the coronary heart of an argument
These incidents happen in a context of sturdy tensions surrounding the arrival of the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra. For a number of days, pro-Palestinian organizations (together with Urgence Palestine, Artistes pour la Palestine and BDS France) have been calling for the occasion to be canceled, accusing the Philharmonic of “normalizing” Israeli coverage. The CGT-Spectacle had, in a press launch dated October 29, criticized the dearth of “political contextualization” of the live performance.
To Discover
Kangaroo of the day
Answer
In response, one other petition signed by a number of classical music figures, together with Martha Argerich, Natalie Dessay and Evgeny Kissin, defended the orchestra, recalling that its members “come from diverse backgrounds” and that Lahav Shani “is neither diplomat nor propagandist, but a musician”. The political class, for its half, was primarily behind the condemnation of those acts. Rachida Dati, Minister of Culture, denounced “an unacceptable intrusion of violence into a concert hall”. The president of Crif, Yonathan Arfi, who was additionally current within the room, spoke of “hateful agitators” and requested for “exemplary sanctions” on X.
On the left, Jean-Luc Mélenchon thought-about that the protest couldn’t be prevented, whereas referring to the “humanitarian drama” in Gaza. Already, in September, conductor Lahav Shani had been the topic of political stress in Belgium, the place he had been canceled from the Ghent Festival. The musician then denounced “demands contrary to his commitment to peace”.
https://www.lepoint.fr/culture/philharmonie-de-paris-quatre-mises-en-examen-apres-les-heurts-lors-du-concert-de-l-orchestre-d-israel-09-11-2025-2602751_3.php