‘Homo Argentum’, the newest movie by Argentine administrators starring Guillermo Franchela, has unleashed a storm in his nation as a consequence of its acidic and ruthless portrait of his compatriots and numerous political controversies that embrace Milei and Cristina Fernández de Kirchner: Cohn and Duprat, administrators of ‘Homo Argentum’: “We belong to a progressive world, that is why we have the authority to criticize their hypocritical homilies” | Cinema: premieres and critiques | EUROtoday
They barely needed to talk out final summer season. Mariano Cohn and Gastón Duprat solely needed the general public to resolve and react to their new success, silver man when it rose to phenomenon standing having grow to be one of the vital watched movies in theaters in its nation with nearly two million viewers. With that determine it now reaches Spanish theaters, the place they hope that success and, why not, controversy will unfold. Her compatriots inspired her after taking up the rooms after which giving their opinions for and in opposition to. In favor of those that see on this acidic and uncooked portrait of right this moment’s Argentina with Guillermo Francella embodying 16 completely different roles, a hilarious and actual compendium of his countrymen: from the village priest to numerous black businessmen, from the hypocritical filmmaker king of posturing to the ghost grandfather or the household able to skinning themselves for a dwelling inheritance; from the virtually forty-year-old son barricaded in his dad and mom’ home to the ultra-violent neighborhood braggart or the blocked president of the republic. Against them they’ve those that have requested that even their passports be taken away and so they be expelled from the nation as pariahs. The creators of collection like Nothing y The supervisor or motion pictures like The illustrious citizen y official competitors They as soon as once more put their finger on the wound and present themselves enemies of indifference.
Ask. His cinema is a continuing portrait of Argentina, removed from patriotic speeches, why have such livid assaults been unleashed with this movie and never earlier than?
Gaston Duprat. For or in opposition to, it provides me nice pleasure to hearken to the movie’s rebounds, the controversy and the kicking are a worth of it for the reason that unanimity of opinions relating to a creative work appears unhappy to me, we depart that to these monument movies that some name mandatory, the reign of solemnity: a horror. There was a refrain of chauvinist voices that harangued in opposition to the movie to defend the nationwide being supposedly sullied by us. Some critics have been so offended that they begged their readers to not go to the films. There was anger from politicians, actors, journalists, artists, analysts, unions, and Catholic establishments. Of course, many different individuals have been fascinated by the movie: critics, journalists, fellow filmmakers and actors who praised it. There have been hours and hours of tv and pages and pages of newspapers discussing the movie day-after-day. We all the time appreciated to place our finger within the socket, we have been aggravated and offended by our cinema though it’s true that not within the astronomical dimension of The Silver Man.
Mariano Cohn. If you add to that debate the viewers filling the rooms, with two million viewers to this point, the happiness is full. The worst vacation spot for a movie is to fall asleep in an artwork movie show or a museum, it is just like the place the place whales go to die. For The Silver Man We privileged individuals within the halls over the festivals: with all of the ache on the planet we declined invites from two crucial European festivals, and we selected what was greatest for the inflow of the general public within the halls. And fortunately the guess turned out very effectively.
P. Not all the things has been assaults, however maybe some reward has helped little, within the case of Milei. Why do you assume he may have appreciated it when some portraits signify the cruel profile of his voter?
G. D. It is yet another opinion among the many greater than one million opinions of those that went to see it in Argentina. Everyone can do it. Viewers have resignified the movie from one aspect to the opposite. It is now not our movie and any interpretation is legitimate, even when we do not prefer it or it appears removed from what we expect.

P. On the opposite hand, there are the paradigms of tradition woke thrown to the bottom. One of people who has most outraged is that of the village priest. How does it harm?
G. D. It bothered progressivism loads as a result of the village priest is a banner, for them he’s good in particular person: right this moment, in Argentina, progressives include a crucifix. We don’t assume that and the cartoon makes it specific: it reveals the hypocrisy and mocks the village priest’s speech, which is predicated on actual phrases by Bergoglio concerning the “virtues” of poverty.
M. C. There have been indignant complaints from Church authorities in Argentina, which makes me proud. Argentine cinema has made a cult of poverty, filming distress after which displaying it at European festivals.
P. There can be the arbitrary movie director on the set and immaculately going through the gallery. Do they insist on not being appreciated by their individuals?
G. D. I feel we fell brief with the portrait of the movie director. The hypocrisy and pretense of artists—administrators, actors—once they go on stage to obtain an award, and as an alternative of thanking them and going dwelling, they stun us with their speeches by which they assist all of the noble causes there are: that starvation on the planet, that immigration, that oiled penguins… are a calamity. That world, to illustrate progressive, is a world to which we belong. That is why we have now the authority to criticize his hypocritical homilies.

P. Milei has used his movie for a while to not converse publicly about his latest corruption instances. How do you’re feeling about being a distraction from public debate?
M. C. The movie was a unprecedented success with the general public and a supply of social debate a number of days earlier than the president talked about it. He highlighted it for being a high-grosser and never being made with public funds from the Argentine Film Institute, the controversial INCAA. The variety of viewers, for my part, will not be a worth in itself: there are superb blockbuster movies and a few very unhealthy ones, and indie movies with little or no viewers which are extraordinary and others which are horrible.
G. P. I inform you extra: our movie The man subsequent door (2010), a dispute between two neighbors over a celebration wall drawback, undoubtedly with the identical gene as the remainder of our work, together with The Silver Manwas interpreted by the federal government of the time, Peronism—the opposition to Milei—as a vindication of that political occasion. In my opinion, a really compelled evaluation, removed from our intention, however legitimate, as a result of everybody can assume no matter they need. Third occasion interpretations aren’t inside our attain. At the Government House they then requested us for 300 DVD copies to provide away, as a result of they appreciated it a lot.
M. C. When we did the collection Nothing with Robert De Niro in Buenos Aires, day-after-day we acquired strain from the manager department to get a photograph with the determine and be part of the collection. They have been capable of be prevented, fortunately.
G. D. In any case, it is rather rudimentary to divide artistic endeavors in response to political ideologies, to go to the cinema to measure the ideological affinity of a movie, and based mostly on that to love it or not. That’s a really silly factor. I guarantee you that the widespread public, the one which has crammed theaters all through Argentina, doesn’t assume like that, it’s extra free and complicated.

P. Cristina Fernández de Kirchner requested to see her and apparently stated that Milei had not came upon.
M. C. We solely heard on a tv information that she had requested for a hyperlink to the producers to see it at dwelling. Whatever you say, whether or not you appreciated it or not, it is going to be simply one other opinion amongst a whole lot of 1000’s.
G. D. A journalist took the ridiculous bother of learning and publishing the ideological place and concluded that of the 16 tales, six could possibly be interpreted as essential of the appropriate, 5 of the left, and the identical variety of impartial ones. Unusual.
G. D. The Silver Man It is now not only a film, it’s the film plus all the things that occurred with it, the entire thing: the social impression, the controversy, the controversy, the individuals filling the theaters, all of the TV channels speaking concerning the film on the similar time, the followers, the detractors, the critics for, in opposition to, those that applauded standing, those that have been offended, all the things added up and constructed the phenomenon.
P. What is most annoying about your Argentine portrait?
M. C. They are frightened about seeing themselves within the mirror. Obviously our portrait is a partial lower of the Argentine, it might be very conceited to assume that we are able to synthesize everybody within the movie, we didn’t have that goal. They additionally accuse us of being misanthropes. I do not see it that manner, there are lots of noble and heat characters within the movie, but when that have been the case, what can be the issue? We are speaking a couple of film, not a humanism guide.
G. D. There are great misanthropic authors from Jean Paul Sartre to Thomas Bernhard, Michel Houellebecq or Lars Von Trier. There is one thing very backward in pretending that artwork ought to all the time be optimistic and constructive, that’s one thing very cavemanish.
P. Some have requested to go away the nation. Do they worry violent reactions?
M. C. No, however it’s true that there have been those that requested to remove our nationality, or critics who known as us stateless or anti-Argentine. That’s fabulous, worthy of a vignette. The Silver Man. The concept that we administrators are anti-Argentine or stateless is nonsense, one thing that isn’t even sufficient to defend itself. Hundreds of movies from around the globe harshly criticize society with out receiving such obscurantist criticism. We have been by no means afraid to be essential, we are going to proceed to precise our standpoint, have little doubt. Let the offended put together, as a result of we’re already getting ready The Silver Man 2
P. Is Guillermo Francella the best chameleon paradigm of the typical Argentine?
M. C. He is a unprecedented actor, a primary comic, not solely in Argentina, however I dare say on the planet. Here he makes at least 16 very completely different characters, all constructed with nice depth and an unimaginable degree of element.
G. D. Our pal, the large Argentine actor Oscar Martínez, as soon as stated that Guillermo is greater than an actor, he’s a pop phenomenon.
https://elpais.com/cultura/2025-12-25/cohn-y-duprat-directores-de-homo-argentum-pertenecemos-al-mundo-progre-por-eso-tenemos-autoridad-para-criticar-sus-homilias-hipocritas.html