The PP of Isabel Díaz Ayuso registered this Friday within the Madrid Assembly the modification of the 2 trans-regional legal guidelines, which it had modified simply 10 months in the past. The rectification has come after the central authorities and the Ombudsman, Ángel Gabilondo, took completely different factors of each rules to the Constitutional Court, which had thus been suspended. Although the conservatives defend that the modifications solely adapt to the opinions of the Council of State of March 21, 2024 the texts of the regulation on safety, efficient equality and non-discrimination of transsexual and intersex individuals, referred to as ley transand the regulation of safety, efficient equality and non-discrimination of LGTBI individuals, the reality is that the adjustments have an effect on the factors that brought on the controversy and painting the try to forestall the Constitutional Court from altering them.
“Ayuso’s PP backs down on its trans law for fear of the ruling of the Constitutional Court, and that it forces them to change them,” says Jimena González, a consultant of Más Madrid. “The new wording protects a little more the right to privacy of trans people in locker rooms and bathrooms in schools and juvenile centers, sheltered flats, etc.,” he argues. “It also greatly softens the wording of the requirement for a medical report before a minor can receive hormonal treatment,” he continues. “This was the main point of unconstitutionality,” he recollects. “And we go from saying that psychological counseling could never be considered conversion therapy, when we know that it often is, to saying that psychological counseling should seek to protect health and be limited to informing.”
“It is a modification that rectifies two issues in particular, one the mandatory medical report for trans minors, and two, it greatly softens the issue of the use of clothing by trans children and adolescents,” summarizes Santiago Rivero, PSOE deputy. “It was an outcry, and in the end time has proven us right that the PP was wrong in discriminating against and pathologizing trans people again,” he added. “This modification is a triumph of the truth and dignity of trans people.”
It all began in December 2023, when Ayuso’s PP authorized the 2 reforms within the regional Parliament, upsetting protests from the left-wing opposition, which noticed them impressed by Vox, and complaints from LGTBI teams, who mobilized to point out his rejection of the modifications.
Four months later, Gabilondo, former spokesperson for the PSOE within the Assembly, and now Ombudsman, introduced in April the submitting of an attraction for unconstitutionality towards a paragraph of an article of the ley trans which establishes the duty that trans minors who wish to obtain hormonal therapy have assist from youngster and adolescent psychological well being professionals, and preserve it all through the method.
Two months later, when the Madrid legal guidelines had solely been in power for six months, the central authorities introduced its personal attraction, on this case towards particular facets of each rules.
Thus, he denounced, on the one hand, the exception that within the authorities’s opinion is made to absolutely the prohibition of conversion therapies, by permitting psychological counseling or psychiatric analysis. On the opposite hand, it targeted on the pathologization that, the Ministry of Equality considers, is completed to trans minors, “by forcing them to undergo a process of psychological or psychiatric support and obtain a favorable medical report as a condition for starting treatment for their transition”.
The “discrimination” that Madrid rules apply to trans individuals versus ladies and women was additionally appealed when they’re allowed to make use of areas or tools “without prejudice to the rights and privacy of other users, especially girls and women.” . And lastly, the “invasion” of procedural and administrative powers that the Government considers that the norm authorized by Ayuso does by excluding LGTBIQ organizations from the standing of events in legal and administrative sanctioning procedures, even after they characterize a sufferer or individual. harmed along with your specific permission.
Although the Community of Madrid, via counselor Ana Dávila, accused the Government of “lying,” a number of of the facets appealed to the Constitutional Court are amongst those who the PP now modifies motu proprio within the regional Assembly. These are adjustments that may be taken without any consideration, for the reason that conservatives have an absolute majority in Parliament.
Thus, part 3 of article 13 of the trans regulation is modified to restrict that “psychological counseling and, where appropriate, psychiatric evaluation of health personnel, will be limited to informing, with a scientific basis and medical guarantees, the person transsexual, seeking the protection of their health.”
In addition, letter b) of part 2 of article 14 is modified to remove the duty for minors who’re going to start to transition to obtain assist from youngster and adolescent psychological well being professionals. From the “necessary requirement” contained within the present regulation, the wording is way much less restrictive: “Prior to the beginning of pharmacological treatment, and throughout the process, the minor will receive support from child and adolescent mental health professionals.”
Two different modifications are made in order that areas or tools recognized primarily based on intercourse, resembling altering rooms or bogs, can’t solely be used with “full respect” for the transsexuality of the customers, but additionally with “full respect for the needs, rights and and intimacy.”
Regarding Law 3/2016, of July 22, on safety, efficient equality and non-discrimination of LGTBI individuals within the Community of Madrid, letter d) of article 65 is deleted.
The widespread events request that this modification be made via a single studying – which prevents parliamentary debate – and within the clarification of causes it’s detailed that the target is to “appropriate facets of the unique wording of the legal guidelines that have been prone to violate elementary rights , whereas the regional legal guidelines have been tailored to the lately authorized state regulation.”
https://elpais.com/espana/madrid/2024-10-11/ayuso-rectifica-sus-leyes-lgtbi-antes-de-que-el-constitucional-resuelva-los-recursos-del-gobierno-y-el-defensor-del-pueblo.html