The unanswered questions after Gisele Pelicot rape trial | EUROtoday

Following three months of harrowing authorized proceedings, Gisele Pelicot’s ex-husband – and 50 males he recruited to sexually abuse her over the course of a decade – had been this week sentenced for his or her crimes.

In a case that has shocked the world, Dominique Pelicot, dubbed the “Beast of Avignon”, was discovered to have spent a decade drugging his spouse and organising for strangers he met on-line to rape her unconscious physique.

An electrician nearing retirement, Pelicot’s crimes had been found when he was caught up-skirting a lady in a grocery store, main police to search out his catalogue of greater than 20,000 movies documenting the abuses he facilitated at their house in southeastern France.

On Thursday, he was jailed for 20 years as 5 judges returned their verdicts at Avignon’s Palais de Justice.

Of the 50 males who stood trial alongside him – three quarters of whom had households of their very own, and labored in roles corresponding to firefighters, journalists, nurses, and jail guards – 47 had been discovered responsible of rape, two of tried rape, and two of sexual assault. They had been jailed for a complete of 428 years.

Here are a number of the questions that stay unanswered following this week’s verdict.

Could Gisele Pelicot return to the courtroom?

Having spent three months in courtroom going through down the lads who abused her, the 72-year-old has turn out to be an icon and image of braveness to many, with scores of supporters ready exterior the courtroom to applaud her every day.

(AFP/Getty)

Following the decision, her lawyer Stephane Babonneau mentioned: “At the start of the trial she said: ‘If I last two weeks, that will be a lot.’ In the end, she made it to three and a half months. Now, she is at peace, and relieved it’s all over.”

However it stays unclear whether or not Gisele might return to courtroom if a lot of these convicted are to attraction.

On Friday, French media reported that the lawyer for Redouan El Farihi, 55, and Ahmed Tbarik, 54, had lodged appeals after they had been every discovered responsible of rape and sentenced to eight years in jail. Dominique Pelicot can be mentioned to be contemplating interesting towards his jail sentence.

While these convicted can have 10 days to lodge an attraction, Ms Babonneau advised France Inter radio: “In any case, she has no fear of it [another trial]that is what she told us.”

Is Dominique Pelicot responsible of additional crimes?

Investigators at the moment are formally probing whether or not Pelicot might have been a serial offender previous to the crimes he dedicated towards his spouse between 2011 and 2020.

(Handout)

Two chilly instances – the 1991 rape and homicide of an property agent in Paris, and the tried rape of an property agent in 1999 – have now been reopened, and Pelicot might doubtlessly face trial sooner or later.

While he has admitted to assault and tried rape within the 1999 case, after DNA testing following his arrest discovered his blood matched that discovered on the sufferer’s shoe, Pelicot has denied any accountability within the 1991 case, though prosecutors argue the 2 instances are too just like be coincidental.

What occurred to Pelicot’s daughter?

In November 2020, as she and her brother had been urgently transferring their mom out of her household house after her father’s crimes had been found, Caroline Darian was summoned to return to the police station to listen to one thing that officers might solely inform her in individual.

Already reeling from the devastating revelations of her father’s actions, Ms Darian was proven two pictures amongst her father’s catalogue of a younger girl on a mattress wearing lingerie. While she initially didn’t recognise the lady, the reality dawned on her as an officer identified she and the lady within the footage each shared the identical mole on their cheek.

“How could he have photographed me in the middle of the night without waking me? Did he also drug me? Worse still, did he abuse me?” Ms Darian later wrote in a memoir And I finished calling you dad (And I finished calling you father).

Despite additionally being discovered responsible of this act, in addition to taking indecent photographs of his daughters-in-law, Aurore and Celine, Pelicot insisted throughout the trial that he “did nothing” to his daughter, who was heard shouting to him: “I’ll never see you again! You’ll die alone like a dog!”

Gisele Pelicot (R) sits beside her daughter Caroline Darian (C) and her son (L) on the courthouse throughout the trial (AFP by way of Getty Images)

Despite his denials, the query stays over how far Pelicot’s abuse of his daughter went. Ms Darian stays satisfied that her father not solely checked out her “with incestuous eyes”, but additionally drugged her and should have bodily abused her.

In courtroom, she described herself because the trial’s “forgotten victim”, with no document of the abuse she believes happened.

How do Gisele Pelicot’s rapists view their crimes?

During the trial, most of the dozens of males discovered to have raped Gisele gave a mess of makes an attempt to justify their actions – insisting both that Pelicot had given his consent for them to rape his spouse, that they had been in actual fact additionally Pelicot’s unwitting victims, or that they’d an excessive amount of testosterone.

“She was waiting for the explanations, some kind of exchange, and she has not had that,” Gisele’s lawyer Antoine Camus advised the courtroom.

(Reuters)

Describing their excuses as proof of a societal “­culture of rape”, Mr Camus later advised The Guardian: “These absurd suggestions, prejudices, hypotheses, ­preconceived ideas … all deployed before our very eyes, and all at the expense of Gisèle Pelicot.”

It stays unclear why not a single man confronted with Gisele’s unconscious and clearly drugged physique would increase the alarm to the police.

“The question is not why you went there, but why you stayed,” Mr Camus advised the courtroom.

How might the trial impression society’s ‘culture of rape’

Ms Pelicot has mentioned that she made her momentous determination to waive her anonymity with a purpose to permit the proceedings and proof to be heard in open courtroom in order that “shame changes sides”.

It is a call that has fuelled a nationwide dialog in France, which campaigners hope will assist to alter attitudes in direction of rape and sexual violence.

The trial has additionally highlighted how French regulation and those that uphold it deal with survivors of sexual violence and questions round consent.

While rape in France is outlined as “sexual penetration, ­committed against another person by violence, constraint, threat or surprise”, with Gisele’s rapists’ prosecuted below the latter class, the trial has intensified discussions round whether or not France ought to add a clause explicitly round consent.

Marion Dubreuil, a courtroom correspondent for radio station RMC who lined the trial near-daily, advised The Guardian: “Rape is the most ­absolute crime; the most banal and the most common. Now we are ­speaking about it, people realise it is ­happening all the time. I see this in those around me. The trial has made them think.”

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/gisele-pelicot-rape-trial-france-b2668438.html