Security: Angraum U -Bahn – Welt | EUROtoday

There are presently sufficient dialogue materials. Negotiations between Washington, Moscow and Kiev about peace, the classification of the AfD by the constitutional safety as nationwide proper -wing extremist, the brand new authorities … however the German capital has found a very completely different battle up to now few weeks – girls’s compartments in public transport.

The Internet raged, and those that exchanged themselves with girls – it is a subjective impression – received even ugly to listen to from in any other case peaceable contemporaries within the occasion of a scarcity of enthusiasm for this concept. In mid-April, the musician of a queer feminist band had began a petition for the introduction of “Flinta” compartments (for girls, lesbians, inter, nonbinaries, trans and agenders), which was signed by 16,000 supporters inside a number of days.

The compartments are to be arrange within the rear areas of the autos, “where attacking men often sit”, as it’s mentioned. I like to take a seat within the again. This stirs from faculty. The cool ones at all times sat within the again. Now I really feel just a little suspicious there. But apparently the queer rocker hit a nerve in Berlin.

Dubai, Cairo, Bangkok and Tehran

Are buses and trains, stops, prepare stations and the encompassing space there, particularly at evening, with poor lighting? Not in all places, however principally: sure. Is the quota of sexual assault on girls alarming? Yes. In Berlin native transport, 380 offenses have been formally registered final yr, greater than sooner or later. So there are causes that might converse for the introduction of girls’s compartments. But one, the essential one, speaks in opposition to it. So you must go away that fully.

The concept of ​​girls’s zones in trains just isn’t as revolutionary, “movements” that “fight” for this and the “fight” usually heat up outdated ideas. The Prussian state railways already had girls’s compartments, in all 4 automobile lessons. The Japanese railways nonetheless have it, the Austrian ÖBB too. There are girls’s zones within the metros of Dubai, Cairo, Bangkok or Rio, within the overhead line buses of Riad or Tehran or the tram of Alexandria. Does the record discover something? Right, there are numerous Islamic nations beneath. Do we would like a religiously motivated seating order in public transport, do we would like an Islamic picture of girls that additionally discover its expression in it? I don’t need that.

Incidentally, ÖBB in Austria came upon years in the past that there’s hardly any demand for such compartments, and the Japanese apparently have such an issue with sexual assault in railways that there’s a phrase for it: “chica”. Can you study from the Japanese lanes? Secure. However, I would favor if you happen to began punctuality, cleanliness and repair. But after all that is extra complicated than devoting a compartment to girls zones. Oddly sufficient, this time doesn’t even need the Berlin transport firms that in any other case take part in each time -minded, politically appropriate nonsense, these girls’s compartments. A number of reserved, purple lined rows of seats could be sufficient for the petitioners.

Perpetrators like victims: males

Now there are girls who say how would “feel uncomfortable” in public transport. For instance, I really feel uncomfortable in Berlin’s subway line 8, the so-called ghost prepare. At any time of the day. Everyone who has their 5 senses collectively achieve this, simply those that are having fun with narcotics there or make them again on web site. Interior Minister Nancy Faeser as soon as mentioned with a view to public transport: “We cannot accept that many women do not move freely at night, because they feel threatened.” And there we’re on the essential level.

It just isn’t a problem that males really feel threatened. A have a look at the crime statistics reveals that by far most perpetrators who exert violence in opposition to individuals, beat, step, stab, choke, thrust, shoot, are males. The victims too. At a big distance. And no males’s compartments assist them, as a result of then you definitely sit down with the characters to which you wish to preserve your distance.

Now there are instances perceived as violence under the edge of brutal uncooked crime: When males begin to do, verbally press, seize, persecute, intimidate, want, develop into attacked. That can go away trauma. Here, too, the evaluation of criminalists ensures an attention-grabbing differentiation: most of those assaults don’t occur in buses and trains. Who are illuminated, have a driver close by the place cameras run. It occurs on the platforms, on the stops, within the space of ​​the stations. The lonely, not illuminated, grubby prepare station is the worst anxiousness house. And what do you do about it? Set up girls’s zones or girls corridors on the paths there and away once more.

Let’s say goodbye to the considerably petty argument “Men are also afraid and are victims”. But the above examples present that every one of those concepts of safety zones don’t deliver a lot, however strengthen the segregation of society – which, by the way, is comfortable to be challenged and promoted by these, in any other case converse for a “colorful society” and “diversity”, to be able to then share a “protected” reserve. The drawback that’s behind the demand for girls’s compartments should be solved in another way. Not with shelters.

The monopoly of violence is an obligation

The state has the monopoly of violence. That’s proper. The railway, public transport are state or quasi -state. The monopoly of violence just isn’t solely a privilege, additionally it is an obligation. The state should be sure that everybody on this nation can reside safely and bodily intact. No matter what gender you’ve got, the place you come from, what you deserve or what you consider or not. In a rustic the place particular person teams want protected areas, the state has failed. It is its central process to supply safety.

Anyone who calls for girls’s compartments signifies undoubtedly displeasure. But he solely appears to be like at his wants, he borders, he doesn’t see the massive image and what’s the actual obligation of those that rule, set up and handle our neighborhood.