Supreme Court Rules Postal Service Cant Be Sued | EUROtoday

WASHINGTON (AP) — A divided Supreme Court on Tuesday dominated that Americans can’t sue the U.S. Postal Service, even when workers intentionally refuse to ship mail.

By a 5-4 vote, the justices dominated in opposition to a Texas landlord, Lebene Konan, who alleges her mail was deliberately withheld for 2 years. Konan, who’s Black, claims racial prejudice performed a job in postal workers’ actions.

Justice Clarence Thomas, writing for a majority of 5 conservative justices, mentioned the federal regulation that usually shields the Postal Service from lawsuits over lacking, misplaced and undelivered mail consists of “the intentional nondelivery of mail.”

In dissent, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that whereas the safety in opposition to lawsuits is broad, it doesn’t prolong to conditions when the choice to not ship mail “was driven by malicious reasons.” Justice Neil Gorsuch joined his three liberal colleagues in dissent.

President Donald Trump’s Republican administration had warned {that a} ruling for Konan would have led to a flood of comparable lawsuits in opposition to the cash-strapped Postal Service.

Konan, who’s additionally an actual property agent and an insurance coverage agent, claims two workers at a publish workplace in Euless, Texas, a part of the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex, intentionally didn’t ship mail belonging to her and her tenants as a result of, she alleges, they didn’t like that she is Black and owns a number of properties.

According to courtroom paperwork, the dispute started when Konan found the mailbox key for one in all her rental properties had been modified with out her information, stopping her from accumulating and distributing tenants’ mail from the field. When she contacted the native publish workplace, she was instructed she wouldn’t obtain a brand new key or common supply till she proved she owned the property. She did so, the paperwork say, however the mail issues continued, regardless of the USPS inspector common instructing the mail to be delivered.

Konan alleges the staff marked among the mail as undeliverable or return to sender. Konan and her tenants did not obtain necessary mail reminiscent of payments, drugs and automobile titles, in accordance with the lawsuit. Konan additionally claims she misplaced rental revenue as a result of some tenants moved out as a result of scenario.

After submitting dozens of complaints with postal officers, Konan lastly filed a lawsuit below the 1946 Federal Tort Claims Act, which permits some lawsuits in opposition to the federal government. The case centered on the attain of the particular postal exemption to the regulation.

Follow the AP’s protection of the U.S. Supreme Court at https://apnews.com/hub/us-supreme-court.