The Ministry of Health's medical atlas begins at the moment | EUROtoday

Get real time updates directly on you device, subscribe now.


As of: May 17, 2024 6:11 a.m

The nationwide medical atlas is scheduled to go surfing at the moment. The Federal Ministry of Health's listing compares hospitals. What does the portal provide – and what’s controversial?

Tina Handel

How does the atlas evaluate the standard of the clinics?

The so-called Federal Clinic Atlas compares the clinics in a area with regard to a particular process, akin to colon most cancers surgical procedure: How usually is the process carried out within the clinic? Is the clinic licensed for this space, i.e. on this case checked by the German Cancer Society?

There can also be details about staffing ranges. “How high is the specialist key, how good is the nursing key? This is highly relevant information,” says Health Minister Karl Lauterbach about his challenge.

Complication charges must also be listed. They can present details about how usually a hip implant is inaccurate or sufferers endure from strain ulcers.

What is especially controversial is that the clinics within the atlas are divided into sure ranges, that are supposed to offer details about the vary of providers.

Where can I discover the portal and what knowledge is already obtainable firstly?

The Ministry of Health's providing will be discovered at Not all data will likely be obtainable there firstly. The web page will likely be crammed progressively. Quality seals, for instance, nonetheless must be checked earlier than they’re all purported to be on-line by 2025. The controversial efficiency teams must also be added.

Patients may very well be confused when attempting to tell apart the Ministry of Health's new portal from different choices – a minimum of after they merely search on Google. There are various business websites with related names, akin to Klinikradar or Klinikatlas. The hospital firm additionally already has a proposal with the German Hospital Directory.

What are ranges and Performance teams?

The portal defines 65 areas of drugs as service teams, akin to cardiac surgical procedure, ophthalmology and obstetric medication. Each hospital is rated based mostly on which of those providers it presents.

This determines which degree of care, referred to as degree, the hospital meets. Level 1 is fundamental suppliers. They provide necessary emergency care, however are usually not as broadly based mostly. Level 2 clinics provide extra, akin to a minimum of two surgical areas. For Level 3, clinics should have a variety obtainable.

Why is that this controversial?

The hospital firm criticizes that the extent classification says “nothing about the quality of the treatment”. “In fact, it will lead to supposed star categories, i.e. levels, misleading patients.” From now on you would choose the big college clinic. It is feared that the extremely specialised division of a smaller clinic may very well be misplaced within the transparency portal.

The federal states additionally see this critically and as an intervention of their hospital planning: truly solely as a part of the hospital reform deliberate by Lauterbach will it’s exactly outlined what service teams are and what ranges of care consequence from this.

The reform, which handed the cupboard in mid-May, is meant to assist clinics specialize. Now the Ministry of Health is already dividing the hospital panorama into sure teams with out ready till all the reform is mentioned within the Bundestag and implement.

Where does the information come from?

The legislation stipulates that clinics should report knowledge quarterly. They criticize the excessive effort. The Marburger Bund medical affiliation speaks of a “further surge in bureaucracy”.

The knowledge is collected by the Institute for Quality Assurance and Transparency in Healthcare (IQTIQ). In addition to medical knowledge, it additionally receives data from certification our bodies or medical health insurance firms. For instance, it checks the importance of high quality seals and certificates and decides what needs to be printed.

How is it ensured that the information is updated?

Experts assume that the information within the portal will all the time be round two years outdated: “In 2024, the latest data available will be from 2022,” says a research by Reinhard Busse, professor of well being administration on the TU Berlin. It simply takes time to boost and study instances.

But for Busse, that is no purpose to doubt the importance of the numbers. He examined how sufferers fared after hip surgical procedure or a coronary heart assault and whether or not the clinics had equally good or unhealthy outcomes two years later. His conclusion: Anyone who does effectively as soon as will later have “30 to 79 percent better results in the treatment area.”

This implies that the older knowledge nonetheless predicts remedy success effectively. There are additionally growing issues the place there have been extra issues two years in the past.

For which sicknesses is it value it? Clinic comparability?

For many forms of most cancers, it makes an enormous distinction whether or not sufferers are handled in a specialised clinic. This was the results of an evaluation by the Government Commission for Hospital Care in 2023. Certified facilities obtain higher outcomes, particularly in relation to breast most cancers and colon most cancers.

It will not be solely necessary for stroke sufferers to be handled rapidly. It can also be essential that the clinic has a so-called stroke unit. According to the research, 5,000 extra sufferers might survive the primary yr after a stroke.

Anyone who wants a hip or knee alternative must also take note of how usually a clinic carries out this process. Experienced practitioners are extra seemingly to achieve success throughout the first operation. Hundreds of follow-up surgical procedures may very well be averted yearly if sufferers select a clinic whose medical doctors have lots of expertise with these hip or knee surgical procedures. The evaluation reveals this too.

Have hospitals been so opaque to date?

If you wish to discover out extra, you want a minimum of lots of time. Hospitals at the moment publish high quality experiences on-line, which are sometimes over 1,000 pages lengthy. It says, for instance, how excessive the consumption of disinfectants is in sure wards or what number of occupational therapists there are.

Health Minister Lauterbach guarantees that higher readability and comparability are a bonus of his portal: “You will then see how houses A, B or C compare to each other. This information is currently not available.” The complication charges, which can be of specific curiosity to many sufferers, are at the moment not so simply obtainable and comparable.

To say one thing Patient advocates to the brand new provide?

They are skeptical and are anxious that sooner or later clinics will pre-sort their sufferers as a way to current themselves as notably profitable on the portal. Older sufferers with a number of sicknesses would usually want longer therapies, that are finally much less seemingly to achieve success. “This can quickly lead to preferential admission of younger, promising patients and a corresponding inpatient orientation,” says Eugen Brysch, board member of the Patient Protection Foundation. Accordingly, he fears that older and chronically in poor health individuals may very well be discriminated towards.

The Ministry of Health rejects such fears. “Methods of risk adjustment are used,” it says considerably technocratically in a solution to a parliamentary query. This implies that age or earlier sicknesses may very well be given particular consideration when evaluating the information and distortions may very well be averted. The ministry guarantees a “fair comparison”.

Patient advocate Brysch additionally criticizes the truth that the portal leaves out many issues that characterize sufferers' on a regular basis lives: lengthy ready instances, a scarcity of contact individuals or the postponement of examinations are additionally necessary elements. But such experiences might most likely solely be included via affected person surveys. Ask round amongst your pals – this may most likely additional affect the choice for or towards a clinic.